Fieldbus & Industrial Networking


Protection for the fieldbus where it is really needed

November 2014 Fieldbus & Industrial Networking

There is always a risk of faults and failures when installation technology is used for process automation, and even reliable and robust communication via fieldbus can be affected. To implement protective measures for fieldbus communication that are both effective and efficient, it is vital to pinpoint the actual level of availability and potential causes of failure.

So what is the experience with availability of fieldbus installations in practice? And which potential causes are actually responsible for failures? Without knowing the answers to these questions, it is hardly possible to increase fieldbus availability long-term by adopting specific protection measures. However, availability calculations are based on descriptions, assumptions, and observations from the theory of probabilities. And here at Pepperl+Fuchs, we have discovered from many years of interaction with users that these calculations are derived from sometimes unrealistic, sometimes even plain incorrect, assumptions. As such, the results are often not a true reflection of reality either.

Discrepancy between theory and practice

It is often, and wrongfully, the case that only the probability of component failure (i.e., the inverse of the actual failure rate) is used to calculate availability. The probability of component failure represents the potential for random failure due to ageing and wear of the component. However, this means that important systematic criteria are not being taken into account. In practice, these criteria play a decisive role in availability: When environmental influences and the mode of operation, and their effect are not accounted for in the calculation, a significant discrepancy arises between the mathematical theory and the effect in practice when it comes to process automation. However, a brief glance at alarm and failure statistics makes it very clear that it is precisely the effects of the mode of operation and environmental conditions that are responsible for faults much more frequently than random faults that cause component failure.

To increase availability long-term, it is therefore crucial to identify the typical causes of faults. As part of a long-term project fault conditions and their causes and effects on the fieldbus infrastructure were studied. The results of the project indicate that systematic failures are the most likely causes of failure in plant operation. In addition to the poor design and planning of segments or failures in the installation, typical causes of failure include:

* Shorts circuits, contact bounce, and overloading that occur as a result of work on the segment.

* Surges caused by lightning strikes and a reduction in the performance of lightning protection that has previously gone unnoticed.

* Water penetration in field devices and junction boxes as a result of environmental influences or mode of operation, i.e., through heavy rainfall, condensation due to high humidity levels, use of high-pressure cleaners, and incorrect or faulty seals.

If the assessment of fieldbus technology it reduced only to competition among manufacturers to provide lower failure rates, the assessment is not accounting for maximum availability and is thus puts the user at a disadvantage.

Heuristic assessment of availability

As the purely mathematical calculation of the actual availability of a plant is not a realistic representation, the actual failure rates can be evaluated in another way. The actual or possible fault conditions of plant operation must be recorded for each assessment. A table in which the causes, their probability of occurrence, and impact are recorded has proven a very practical means of assessment. The product of the probability of occurrence and the impact represents the risk indicator. This analytical approach similar to an FMEA analysis (Failure Mode and Effects Analysis) makes it possible to take all potential causes of failure into account.

In such a table, the failure scenarios are assigned to possible protection methods as a solution. Taking an heuristic approach, each solution – regardless of whether it is a particular feature, component, a redundant design, or an operating procedure to avoid failures – is given a key performance indicator calculated using the associated risk indicators. A high indicator means that the measure prevents several very critical failures. This approach makes it clear which action protects against which potential causes of failure. The extent of the failure risk can also be compared with the cost and complexity of the solution. The efficacy and efficiency of the protective actions are therefore guaranteed to the same degree.

Purely mathematical calculations are not suitable for representing the complex array of potential causes of failure in practice. Consequently, the measures derived are also not tailored to the actual failure itself. In practice, it is often the more expensive and, in fact, irrelevant measures and redundancy concepts that are implemented, which ultimately do little to improve availability.

The right solution for every failure

The correct method for determining availability and actual causes of failure is of little help, of course, without the technical solutions that can effectively protect against the fault scenarios identified. Based on the in-depth studies that it has conducted regarding fault conditions in the fieldbus infrastructure, Pepperl+Fuchs has developed a new generation of components, specifically tailored to typical failure scenarios.

The new intelligent components bring diagnostic capability into the field and thus allow continuous error detection. A wide range of new diagnostic functions and fault-handling features limit faults in such a way that the process automation system remains in operation thus increasing overall plant availability. As a result, all information can be transferred via normal fieldbus communication, without additional costs being incurred.

The main feature of the new technology is the well-known Advanced Diagnostic module. This module monitors the physical layer, detects notifications from the downstream components capable of diagnostics, and forwards the notifications to the control system.

The Segment Protector, which is capable of performing diagnostics, offers progressive short circuit protection with excellent fault isolation. The intelligent diagnostic function detects and isolates faults such as contact bounce at spurs.

The Advanced Diagnostic Gateway acts as an interface between the Advanced Diagnostic modules and the control system, responding quickly and reliably to each error. A new I/O function also allows the control system cabinet itself to be monitored.

The diagnostics surge protection offers lightning protection with a self-monitoring function. It protects the fieldbus and field devices from lightning strikes or voltage spikes and emits an alarm signal when its function reserve is exhausted.

The intelligent leakage sensor can be connected to field devices as well as in marshalling cabinets, providing fast and reliable detection of the slightest change in moisture.

All new components are suitable for Foundation Fieldbus H1 and Profibus PA protocols. The new technology is incredibly easy to implement. The components are simply connected and then run without any further configuration – without fieldbus addresses or integration within the control system. The diagnostic functions can be put into operation quickly, easily and economically.For more information contact Mark Bracco, Pepperl+Fuchs, +27 (0)87 985 0797, mbracco@za.pepperl-fuchs.com, www.pepperl-fuchs.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

EtherCAT interoperability removes industrial networking barriers
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Selecting the right communication technology is one of the most important decisions engineers make, and interoperability helps with that decision. Key development tools and standards ensure interoperability among many EtherCAT devices and manufacturers.

Read more...
Condition monitoring to go
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Anyone who wants to efficiently monitor the climate in control cabinets will find a comprehensive range of control cabinet monitors for the DIN rail in Turck Banner’s cabinet condition monitoring family.

Read more...
A new standard in high-speed Ethernet communication
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The TXMC897 module from TEWS Technologies supports a range of Ethernet standards and speeds, making it suitable for diverse applications, including the defence, industrial, and IIoT markets.

Read more...
Data-driven battery production
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The availability of high-performance batteries at moderate prices is one of the most important factors for the success of electromobility. As a long-standing automation partner to the automotive industry, Turck Banner supports the major battery manufacturers with its know-how.

Read more...
Bring critical temperature data to your condition monitoring system
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Data conversion just got easier. Turck Banner converters are compact, simple add-ons that seamlessly fit into your factory applications. You can take various types of signals such as discrete, analogue and many others, and convert them to protocols like IO-link, PICK-IQ, PWM/PFM, and Modbus.

Read more...
RFID made simple
Pepperl+Fuchs Industrial Wireless
Pepperl+Fuchs now offers a practical solution for users looking for an easy entry into the world of RFID with all its possibilities. The new F191 RFID read/write device combines the advantages of sophisticated industrial UHF technology with a standardised interface for IO-link communication.

Read more...
Case History 190: Measurement problem ruins level control.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The widely held belief in many plants that tuning will solve all base layer control problems is completely fallacious. Bad tuning is generally not the main reason for loops to perform badly. It is important when performing optimisation that all elements in a loop are considered, in addition to the control strategy, before even thinking of tuning.

Read more...
Precise part machining
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
toolcraft manufactures on behalf of its customers using its 60 CNC machines, and designs, plans and builds turnkey production systems for companies in various industries, having added injection moulding, mould making and additive manufacturing technologies along the way. Robotics is the company’s newest technology division. This is why toolcraft relies on PC-based control, including in the production cells, which have seven-axis milling robots for machining components at CNC level.

Read more...
Fully digital vertical roller mills
Loesche South Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Vertical roller mills are found in mining and cement milling operations worldwide. They require complex technology for their operation. As a leader in this field, LOESCHE has proven software solutions for digitalisation that can optimise each piece of milling equipment for energy efficiency, and increase its availability and output, making the plant easy to operate.

Read more...
CNC cycle package for triple-axis milling and drilling
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Beckhoff provides a comprehensive package of different cycles for triple-axis milling and drilling machines with the TwinCAT 3 CNC milling base.

Read more...