classic | mobile
 

Search...

SA Instrumentation & Control Buyers' Guide

Technews Industry Guide - IIoT 2018

Technews Industry Guide - Maintenance, Reliability & Asset Optimisation

 

One way wireless
December 2011, Data Acquisition & Telemetry


In the years leading up to the end of the 2001 – 2010 decade end-users who were considering the adoption of industrial wireless technology for instrument signals were faced with two options, each gathering their own proponents, and each coming from a different perspective: these were (in the blue corner) the WirelessHART (IEC/PAS 62591) team and (in the red corner) the ISA100 (ISA-100.11a) team. In the last three years a third player, WIA-PA (IEC/PAS 62601), originating from China, has joined the fray.

Various commentators have likened the battle of the industrial wireless standards to that between VHS and Betamax in the dim and distant past. And for all the hot air that was generated, both those technologies got overtaken by rotating optical storage solutions which themselves may soon disappear.

So should you wait to adopt wireless or should you make an informed decision now and live with that?

Convergence drivers

Large end-users have put pressure on the IEC/PAS 62591 and ISA100 groupings to provide a convergence route map. There are sound commercial and operational reasons for such convergence and the advantages of such convergence appear to be mutually beneficial for both end-users and vendors.

From an end-user perspective the benefits include:

* A wider choice of field instrumentation since the vendor pool becomes the totality of IEC/PAS 62591 and ISA100 manufacturers.

* A more competitive supply side environment, for the same reason.

* Lower on-site maintenance spares holdings because (large) end-users would not need to hold both IEC/PAS 62591 and ISA100 field instrument spares.

* Reduced investment in training since they would not need to train on both systems.

* Reduced investment in infrastructure since they would not need to hold, for instance, handheld devices for provisioning wireless devices.

* Overall reduced lifecycle costs.

From a vendor perspective the benefits include:

* Faster global adoption of wireless technology since end-users would not be stuck in the choice dilemma. In an October 2010 report1 from ARC Advisory Group the potential revenue increase resulting from faster adoption was postulated at up to hundreds of millions of US Dollars.

* A larger potential market since they would be able to market to all potential instrument purchasers.

Convergence status

Both ISA100 (Working group WG12) and NAMUR have active programs in place to determine roadmaps to convergence and there is a working communication channel between NAMUR and ISA on the subject. The ISA100.12 convergence subcommittee initiated a Convergence User Requirements Team that submitted reports both to ISA and to NAMUR in 2010. NAMUR produced report NE133: Wireless Sensor Networks: Requirements for convergence of existing standards, addressing the issue.

In 2010 NAMUR also entered into discussion with WIA-PA with a view to that standard also being included in convergence discussions. Can 1 340 000 000 (that is approximately 20% of the world’s population) ever really be wrong?

What are the differences?

Perhaps the starting point to answering this question is to look at where WirelessHART and ISA-100.11a originated.

In the case of WirelessHART, at a simplistic level, it was developed as a wireless extension to the existing wired HART communications protocol. That has some impact on its applicability, design and even on the level of security incorporated into the standard.

In the case of ISA-100.11a it evolved as probably the most obvious member of the ISA100 standards family. That means that it was envisaged as a part of a much greater whole than WirelessHART. For instance, ISA100 also embraces the use of wireless for real-time field-to-business systems for interfacing work order systems, Control LAN, business LAN and voice. It was also in its infancy as the greater need for security for plant control systems was rearing its ugly head and while the world was busy running out of IPv4 addresses. That means that perhaps more emphasis was put on embedding security into the standard and that IPv6 addressing is embraced. Unlike WirelessHART, ISA-100.11a supports the concept of sensor network subnets, offering greater expansion potential.

A detailed technical comparison of WirelessHART and ISA-100.11a performed as part of Gengyun Wang’s MSc thesis4 concludes that “ISA100.11a offers a vaster coverage and broader view of process automation solutions” and cites aspects such as latency minimisation, management of QoS, security and object orientation.

Table 1 shows typical devices and device roles for each of WirelessHART and


ISA-100.11a. Unfortunately, with the final draft of WIA-PA only released in October 2011, there is insufficient information in the public domain to include comparative details for WIA-PA.

Table 1. Comparison of devices and roles: WirelessHART vs. ISA-100.11a
Table 1. Comparison of devices and roles: WirelessHART vs. ISA-100.11a

Figures 1 and 2 respectively show typical system architectures for WirelessHART and ISA-100.11a.

Figure 1. WirelessHART typical system architecture
Figure 1. WirelessHART typical system architecture

Figure 2. ISA-100.11a typical system architecture
Figure 2. ISA-100.11a typical system architecture

The terminology and purpose of devices differs a little between the standards, and in many cases a single device may perform multiple roles (for instance a WirelessHART Gateway may actually embody Adapter, Gateway, Security Manager and Network Manager), so Table 1 and Figures 1 and 2 should be considered as comparative guidelines only. Readers should refer back to the standards themselves for a deeper understanding of these roles.

Channel hopping

One of the challenges that secure industrial wireless communications has to address is that of ever-increasing traffic on the unrestricted 2,40 GHz ISM band on which all of these industrial wireless standards are built. This same band is shared by Zigbee, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, smartphones, wireless telephone handsets, security cameras, baby monitors, remote controls and a plethora of other devices. Simply put: the airwaves are crowded in this band.

At the same time there is the growing concern about eavesdropping on industrial wireless for the purpose of sabotage.

Over and above the use of 128-bit security keys, which help to foil eavesdropping attempts, secure industrial wireless uses channel hopping, slow channel hopping, channel whitelisting and blacklisting. These channel hopping communication strategies are handled by the Network Manager or System Manager and there are some significant differences in the complexity and configurability of channel hopping strategies between WirelessHART and ISA-100.11a.

Take the plunge

At the start of this article I posed the question: “So should you wait to adopt wireless or should you make an informed decision now and live with that?”

Here is my take on it. If I had a plant where it made economic sense (based on total lifecycle cost) to install a wireless sensor network for some field instruments – perhaps for location reasons (say an effluent plant some distance away from the main operations), or for environmental reasons (signal cabling being damaged by heat/vapours/corrosion ...) or by virtue of moving parts (where sliding contacts, rotary kilns, catenaries and the like can be eliminated) – then I would take the plunge.

Which technology would I plump for? If the majority of my wired field instruments were already HART devices I would stick with HART. Otherwise I would go the ISA-100.11a route.

Would I bet on complete convergence and interoperability between WirelessHART and ISA-100.11a field instruments and infrastructure in the next five years? No.

Would my investment be maintainable and the technology selected supportable for 10 years? Almost certainly.

So what are you waiting for?

References

1. ARC Consulting; ARC Brief: ISA100 and Wireless Standards Convergence; http://www.arcweb.com

2. HART Communication Foundation; The Components of WirelessHART technology; http://tinyurl.com/5rm2zmv

3. International Society of Automation; ISA-100.11a-2009: Wireless Systems for Industrial Automation: Process control and related applications; http://tinyurl.com/6dg3jas

4. Chalmers University Of Technology; Report No. EX036/2011: Comparison and Evaluation of Industrial Wireless Sensor Network Standards ISA100.11a and WirelessHART; http://tinyurl.com/6bo6dnc

Sources and resources

HART Communication Foundation; General information on HART and WirelessHART; http://www.hartcomm.org

International Electrotechnical Commission; IEC 62601: Final Draft: Edition 1.0 2011-08: Industrial Communication Networks – Fieldbus Specifications – WIA-PA Communication Network and Communication Profile; http://tinyurl.com/66ht4p8

International Society of Automation; ISA100, Wireless Systems for Automation; http://www.isa.org/ISA100

ISA100 Wireless Compliance Institute; Background, registered devices, FAQ; http://www.isa100wci.org

About the author

Andrew Ashton has electrical, mechanical and business qualifications and has been active in automation and process control since the early 1980s. Since 1991 he has headed up a company that has developed formulation management systems for the food, pharmaceutical and chemical manufacturing industries and manufacturing solutions involving the integration of various communication technologies and databases. Developed systems address issues around traceability, systems integration, manufacturing efficiency and effectiveness. Andrew is a contributing editor for SA Instrumentation and Control.


Credit(s)
Supplied By: Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control)
Tel: +27 11 543 5800
Fax: +27 11 787 8052
Email: jane@technews.co.za
www: www.technews.co.za
Share via email     Share via LinkedIn   Print this page

Further reading:

  • From the editor’s desk: Fresh start bridges the gap to optimism
    December 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    At last South Africans have something to celebrate as we head into the end-of-year holiday season. Our troubles are far from over of course, but the recent changes in government leadership have given ...
  • EtherCAT roadshow in South Africa
    December 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    Together with the EtherCAT Technology Group (ETG), Technews Publishing recently organised a series of breakfast seminars at venues across the country, in Cape Town, Port Elizabeth, Durban and Johannesburg. ...
  • From the Editor's desk: Digitalisation in the mining industry
    November 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    With South Africa now in recession, and the unemployment rate rising to over 27%, the government’s focus has quite rightly shifted to the issues of job creation and economic stimulus. This has put critical ...
  • From the editor’s desk: Digital transformation includes people, and services
    October 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    Digital transformation, according to Microsoft, is about reimagining how we bring together people, data and processes to create value for customers and maintain a competitive advantage in a digital-first ...
  • New network function for digital ­indicator
    October 2018, Yokogawa South Africa, Data Acquisition & Telemetry
    Yokogawa has added a network function to the UM33A digital indicator with alarms. With this network function, a single UM33A digital indicator can receive, process and sequentially display data from up ...
  • From the Editor's desk: Data centre power consumption set to triple
    September 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    The Internet has become an indispensable part of modern society but we have created a monster, and it’s getting bigger every day. The world’s data centres – those global stores for the estimated 1200 petabytes ...
  • Input invited for SADC engineering study
    September 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    In 2011, the SADC (Southern African Development Community) ministers of science and technology endorsed an engineering needs and numbers study, to get a better understanding of the actual numbers of engineers, ...
  • From the editor’s desk: The changing shape of optical systems
    August 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    A ground-breaking development in smartphone optics looks set to spill over into machine vision and other image-related applications. Unlike the eye, conventional optical systems depend on the movement ...
  • From the editor’s desk: Ignition software, innovation or market disruptor?
    July 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    Innovation itself does not transform a company into a market disruptor, but it is forever a prerequisite. According to Forbes, all disruptors are innovators, but not all innovators are disruptors. Generally ...
  • Remote monitoring and telemetry at power station water plants
    July 2018, Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists, Data Acquisition & Telemetry
    The wireless ability to manage pumps remotely over long distances is now available using Omniflex’s Teleterm M3 Radio RTUs. This full functionality IEC61131 PLC enables both control and wireless communications ...
  • From the editor's desk: Open process automation and digital twins
    June 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), News
    The ideas of The Open Process Automation Initiative first challenged traditional process control thinking at the ARC Industry Forum in 2016. The drive began within the ExxonMobil Corporation where a large ...
  • Scada Review 2018
    June 2018, Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control), SCADA/HMI
    The subject projects of this year’s Scada Review are a worthy reflection of the effort put in by the respondent end-users, SIs and vendors. It is encouraging to see that even in these times of economic ...

 
 
         
Contact:
Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Other
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual





 

         
    classic | mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.