Electrical Power & Protection


Global outlook for nuclear power generation

November 2011 Electrical Power & Protection

In the wake of the disaster at Tokyo Electric’s Fukushima nuclear complex in Japan, Germany, Switzerland, and Italy have moved away from plans for future use of nuclear power. Despite this, the global outlook for the nuclear power market is pretty much the same, since nuclear new-build is highly concentrated in the ‘BRIC’ countries, which – like South Africa – do not plan to abandon nuclear energy.

The European decisions leave a shortfall in generating capacity that will have to be filled quickly. ARC expects that additional wind capacity will fill this shortfall, along with a new generation of combined cycle plants that have been developed for a grid with a much larger share of renewables. Finally, in closing its own nuclear plants, these countries may end up importing nuclear energy from neighbours that have large and expanding fleets of nuclear plants.

The long-term scenario for North America is similar. While North American nuclear retirements will be further off in time, nuclear power will not be replaced at the same rate as retirements, leaving a shortfall to be filled by renewables and highly efficient, gas-fired combined cycle plants.

In South Africa, Eskom appears to be proceeding with plans to build additional conventional (non-PBMR) nuclear generating capacity, along with new coal-fired plants, new hydro capacity, and other renewables. According to one scenario, by 2030, the country’s generation mix should include 48% coal, 13,4% nuclear, 6,5% hydro, 14,5% other renewables, and 11% peaking gas turbine.

In late May 2011, the German government decided to phase out all operating nuclear power plants by the year 2022. Germany shut down its seven oldest nuclear units after the Fukushima accident. These will not be restarted, nor will one newer plant that was shut down for other reasons. Six other operating units will shut down by 2021 and the remaining units by 2022.

Besides Germany, the Swiss government called for the decommissioning of the country’s five nuclear power units. The recommendation will result in a decision that could see the reactors closed down between 2019 and 2034. Italy, which was in the early stages of a nuclear new build programme, has now shelved this initiative.

Minimal impact on global nuclear market

Given such a rapid retreat from nuclear power in Europe, coupled with uncertainty in the US, what is the impact on the global nuclear market? Not very much, ARC believes. Nuclear construction today is concentrated in China, Russia and India. These three countries account for two-thirds of the 66 nuclear power units now under construction worldwide. While these countries are all reviewing their nuclear regulatory policies, none have even spoken of abandoning their goals for nuclear power.

Looking further out in the future toward plants currently in the planning stages, the geographic mix of new plants is still skewed towards the same three countries. They account for half of the future nuclear market at present. Even if some of the larger developed economies continue with plans for nuclear new build (the US, Japan, UK, and South Africa, for example) the number of future plants they might build is a small fraction of those now being planned by BRIC nations.

What will replace European nuclear power?

Turning from the global market back to Europe, the salient question at present is what types of plant will be built to replace the retiring nuclear generating capacity in Germany and Switzerland? The planning, permitting, construction and commissioning of major power projects can easily span five to 10 years. It is not too soon to ask what will replace a German power plant that will retire in 2022. The total nuclear retirements represent about 25 GW of generating capacity that will need to be replaced. ARC believes that three types of generation are most likely to replace these retiring plants: 1) nuclear (yes, nuclear!), 2) wind, and 3) gas-fired combined cycle.

The decision to shut down nuclear power in Germany and Switzerland might actually end up accelerating carbon-free nuclear development in France. French national utility, EDF, could then export the power to the German and Swiss markets. Traditionally Germany has been an electric power exporter, but this situation has changed since its nuclear shutdown.

The second replacement source, also carbon-free, is additional wind generating capacity. Wind now represents 8% of the European generating capacity, but 17% of German capacity. The nuclear units being retired are mainly in southern Germany and Switzerland, so new German offshore wind capacity is disadvantaged by distance. Nevertheless, more rapid retirement of these nuclear units enhance prospects for new wind capacity.

The third generating technology likely to benefit is gas-fired combined cycle. These plants have now achieved a scale and level of thermal efficiency that makes them more competitive. However, their chief differentiator is that, in addition to efficiency, they can be load cycled rapidly. This makes combined cycle plants an effective complement to both wind generation (which is uncontrolled) and nuclear plants, which are based-loaded.

In conclusion, despite a rapid European retreat from nuclear power, the overall impact on the future of the worldwide nuclear industry will not be significant. What these decisions really do is create a policy direction that provides a context in which suppliers and utilities in Europe can make longer term plans. ARC expects a combination of more renewables and new combined cycle fossil-fired designs to take up the slack, first in Germany and Europe, and later in North America. Due to the country’s ample reserves of coal, South Africa, however, will likely continue to utilise a relatively high percentage of coal-fired generation, albeit as a smaller percentage of its overall energy mix.

For more information contact Paul Miller, ARC Advisory Group, +1 781 471 1126, [email protected], www.arcweb.com





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Power portfolio with enhanced static transfer switch for critical applications
Electrical Power & Protection
Vertiv has launched the Vertiv PowerSwitch 7000, a next-generation static transfer switch that strengthens the company’s position as a complete power solutions provider.

Read more...
Why utilities must prioritise maintenance of SA’s remote data
Schneider Electric South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
The story of power generation is more than meets the eye. Beyond energy distribution and the infrastructure are invisible, point of presence data centres located the remotest parts of our country that play a fundamental role in keeping systems running

Read more...
The house that revolutionises substations
WEG Africa Electrical Power & Protection
Traditional substations have major drawbacks in terms of their construction and resilience. One solution is the E-house, a prefabricated, customised and transportable steel structure designed to house a range of electrical and automation equipment.

Read more...
Localised inverter-integrated transformer
Electrical Power & Protection
ACTOM, South Africa’s largest manufacturer, repairer and distributor of electromechanical equipment, is launching a breakthrough in renewable energy integration with its localised inverter-integrated transform

Read more...
Steinmüller Africa integrates advanced technologies at Mondi’s boiler project
Electrical Power & Protection
Steinmüller Africa is leading a boiler project at Mondi’s Richards Bay mill. The 18-month undertaking showcases the company’s blend of engineering excellence and cutting-edge technology.

Read more...
ABB innovation for energy efficiency and sustainability
Electrical Power & Protection
The application of sensor technology to reduce the operational and standby power losses of traditional current and voltage transformers can lead to energy savings of 181 MWh over a 30-year period, the lifetime of a typical switchboard in the African environment.

Read more...
UPS systems are key to keeping SA’s automotive industry up and running
Schneider Electric South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
During loadshedding, PLCs and OT systems often fail, not because they are directly tied to the factory’s core manufacturing process, but because they are now an integral part of IT infrastructure. When an IT system shuts down, the impact is far more complex than simply restarting machinery.

Read more...
ACTOM advances energy infrastructure
Electrical Power & Protection
At this critical juncture where South Africa is poised to modernise its power infrastructure, ACTOM’s Engineering Projects and Contracts (EPC) Division showcased its capabilities for the first time at Enlit Africa 2025.

Read more...
Advanced contactor solution to revolutionise motor management
Schneider Electric South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
Schneider Electric South Africa has launched the TeSys Deca Advanced, an advanced contactor solution designed to revolutionise motor management with unparalleled efficiency, reliability, simplicity and sustainability.

Read more...
Steaming ahead with boiler skills development
Electrical Power & Protection
As an expert in steam and boiler operations and maintenance, AES is very focused on safety, quality, technology advancement and the development of human capital. The company invests heavily in training and the promotion of talented people on an equal opportunity basis into the industrial operations environment.

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved