classic | mobile
 

Search...

SA Instrumentation & Control Buyers' Guide

 

Calculating intrinsically safe loop approvals – Part 2
July 2013, IS & Ex


Subsequent to my previous article published in SA Instrumentation and Control on the subject of calculating an intrinsically safe loop approval (www.instrumentation.co.za/7571a), I will now consider the impact of Exic and how to handle long cable runs in IS loops.

ExnL (Energy Limiting) was a technique used for Zone 2 which was effectively ‘intrinsic safety in normal operation’ i.e. with no safety factor required. ExnL has been reassigned as Exic in IEC/SANS60079-11 and IEC/SANS60079-25. Previously, although not spelt out in the standards, it was generally accepted practice to run ExnL loops in the same trunks as IS loops. With the new standards, it is clear that Exic loops can be run in the same multi-core or trunk as other Exi loops. This means that single multi-core (or trunk) can be used for IS instruments in Zone 0, 1 and 2. NOTE : Shared multicore must be Type A or B in accordance with system standard IEC/SANS 60079-25, that is not subject to faults.

Figure 1.
Figure 1.

Further on this topic: CENLEC standard and subsequently the IEC standard changed the capacitive reference curves because of some tests done in Germany. This reduced the allowed cable capacitance from 2002. This impacts plants built between 1995 and 2002 based on earlier ATEX standards where longer cable runs were required.

For a standard 24 V loop (Uo = 28 V) this changed the Co from 130 nF to 83 nF, reducing the maximum cable length allowed. When these plants require a DCS upgrade and a new isolator is to be fitted, the IS loop calculation now fails.

How can we handle this? Firstly, and importantly, there is a misconception that the Co values are defined by the design of barrier/isolator. The Co value is actually defined in IEC/SANS60079-11: 2012 Table A.2 page 96 (102 of 149). So any barrier/isolator with 28 V safety description will have Co = 83 nF (Zone 0/1; IIC). In practice this parameter will define the maximum allowable cable length.

Figure 2 shows an Exia loop with a Co=83 nF. The max cable capacitance Cc=63 nF. With a typical cable capacitance of 95 nF/km, this would equate to a maximum cable length of 660 metres.

Figure 2.
Figure 2.

If the loop were Exic, the Co=272 nF, so Cc=252 nF would theoretically allow 2,5 km of cable i.e. no longer a limiting factor. (The limiting factor in this system is likely to be the operating voltage at the end of the cable still being high enough to allow the transmitter to work). In Figure 3, the system is Exic certified.

Figure 3.
Figure 3.

Conclusions

1. For new installations requiring long cable runs, classifying the area as Zone 2 offers significant benefit.

2. For upgrading existing plants where the new loop approval fails, there are two options:

* Reclassify the hazardous area as Zone 2, then use Exic and make use of the higher Co value. If this is possible it is the simpler option.

* If it is not possible to reclassify, there is an alternative to be defined in the new ARP0108 due out shortly i.e. there is the availability of a ‘Risk Assessment’ for these loops (Reference in A.10). Note: If a change to loop apparatus results in incompatible safety parameters in accordance with the certification standard, the ATL may consider the use of risk assessment methods and a concession may be issued.

In both cases, Exic offers some flexibility and for upgrades allows for upgrades of old control systems improving safety.

Additional note on equipment for Zone 2: In Europe the ATEX directive allows for Cat 3 self certification (e.g. ExnA non-arcing). Due to the low risk of ignition and high skills proficiency (suppliers and end-users) this is acceptable. Most ExnL ATEX certified products were also Cat 3 self-certified. However with changing to Exic, this is now covered by the third party Exi certification (with minimal extra work or cost), making it an accepted practice in SA.

For reference to Part 1 see October 2012, pages 74 and 75, or refer to www.instrumentation.co.za/7571a

For more information contact Gary Friend, Extech Safety Systems, +27 (0)11 791 6000, gary@extech.co.za, www.extech.co.za


Credit(s)
Supplied By: Extech Safety Systems
Tel: +27 11 791 6000
Fax: +27 11 792 8294
Email: sales@extech.co.za
www: www.extech.co.za
Share via email     Share via LinkedIn   Print this page

Further reading:

  • Trapped key interlocking
    October 2017, Deebar, IS & Ex
    Protecting people, industry and productivity.
  • Safe discharge and monitoring
    October 2017, Stahl Esaco, IS & Ex
    The most frequent cause of electrostatic charge in process plants is charge carryover when filling vessels such as fuel tankers, barrels, big bags or intermediate bulk containers (IBCs). An electrostatic ...
  • New light curtain improves flexibility and safety
    October 2017, Rockwell Automation, IS & Ex
    As production processes become increasingly automated and robots play a larger role on the production line, manufacturers are looking for more ways to maintain and reinforce a safe work environment. ...
  • Emerson launches jar clamp for well integrity
    October 2017, Emerson Automation Solutions, IS & Ex
    Emerson Automation Solutions has launched the latest product within its polymer completions solutions range – the PolyOil jar handling clamp – for increased safety and well integrity. One key threat ...
  • Engineered fire and gas detection systems
    October 2017, Automation & Control Solutions, IS & Ex
    Safety is key in most spheres of life, more so in an industrial environment. Aveng Automation & Control Solutions is the local business partner for Det-Tronics, a global leader in fire and gas safety ...
  • How to calculate an intrinsically safe loop approval
    September 2017, Extech Safety Systems, IS & Ex
    For 24 V systems, intrinsic safety offers a simple and flexible solution for zones 0, 1 and 2.
  • Cable-pull switch enhances industrial safety
    September 2017, Rockwell Automation, IS & Ex
    Industrial automation customers can now improve safety without sacrificing productivity using the Allen-Bradley Guardmaster Lifeline 5 cable-pull switch from Rockwell Automation – a solid-state, cable-pull ...
  • Safety laser scanners immune to wood chippings
    August 2017, SICK Automation Southern Africa, IS & Ex
    Through industrial parquet manufacturing, fine wood flooring has become more affordable and easily available. To achieve production of over 80 million metres of flooring annually, demands stringent requirements ...
  • Efficient solution for simple safety tasks
    August 2017, Countapulse Controls, IS & Ex
    Easy configuration of the Leuze RSL series safety laser scanner via Bluetooth and Ethernet TCP/IP makes this device easy to set up and use. Further, despite the large number of possible field pairs – ...
  • Wireless gas detector for personal monitoring
    August 2017, IS & Ex
    Industrial work for employees can be risky. While many organisations use personal gas monitors to measure for toxic or combustible gases, they are traditionally disconnected and thus cannot call for help. ...
  • Universal process panel meter
    August 2017, Extech Safety Systems, Operator Interfaces, Switches & Relays, IS & Ex
    Beka associates is pleased to announce the introduction of the Advisor A90 universal process meter, designed and manufactured by Beka in the UK to the same exacting standards as its hazardous area indicators ...
  • Timers and clocks for hazardous areas
    August 2017, Extech Safety Systems, Operator Interfaces, Switches & Relays, IS & Ex
    Beka’s new third generation timer/clock’s applications as a timer include simply displaying the time interval between two events detected by a hazardous area sensor. As a clock, local time can be displayed ...

 
 
         
Contact:
Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Other
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual





 

         
    classic | mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.