Electrical Power & Protection


Can IR windows be considered ‘arc resistant’?

March 2017 Electrical Power & Protection

It is easy for an end-user to be misinformed about the specifications of an IR window because there is often confusion in the market about parameters such as arc resistance, IP ratings and environmental stability, in respect of these particular devices. This is particularly true for IR windows manufactured from a crystal substrate, since these are often perceived as being stronger than steel.

Completing an arc containment test on switchgear is required to confirm that the design meets the IEEE and IEC standards, and, if IR windows were installed in the piece of equipment under test, then, if successful, an IR window manufacturer could claim that the window met the IEEE or IEC arc containment requirements for that particular piece of equipment for that particular test. However, a claim of all-encompassing ‘arc resistance’ for that particular IR window would be misleading.

What do the regulations say?

Whilst there are regulations from UL and CSA on IR windows fitted in electrical enclosures up to 600 V, there are no specific regulations from IEEE or IEC. There are however IEEE regulations on ‘visual viewing panes’, which have been in place since the inception of these standards. Like all standards, these have evolved with suppliers’ ability to provide superior, less expensive materials and manufacturing options.

A common theme for all visual viewing pane testing is impact and load testing. This requires the viewing pane to meet a minimum impact and load test without cracking, shattering or dislodging from its housing.

The regulation requires visual viewing panes to withstand impact and load per IEEE C37.20.2 Section a.3.6. Unlike UL, this IEEE standard does not differentiate between the types of material, or give exemptions to crystal infrared windows. Instead it clearly specifies that any transparent material covering an observation opening and forming a part of the enclosure should be reliably secured in such a manner that it cannot be readily displaced in service and not shatter, crack, or become dislodged when both sides of the viewing panes in turn are subjected to impact and load.

This testing method has been in place for many years and is the accepted method for visual viewing panes, so why not use the same test for IR windows? Well, the fact is that the fluoride-based crystal IR windows cannot pass any form of impact, so the IR window manufacturers lean more towards the UL regulation UL1558 for impact and load testing.

Two different test criteria

UL 1558 is the impact and load standard for visual viewing and IR window testing. This test is identical to the IEEE C37.20.2 Section a.3.6 test, except they doubled the load and impact test.

On the face of it, this sounds perfect. But herein lies the rub, unlike the IEEE test, UL1558 has two different test criteria: one with covers fitted and closed on the IR window, and one for covers opened or removed.

When provided with a cover, results are considered to be acceptable if the assembly prevents insertion of a 13 mm diameter rod at the conclusion of the test. When no cover is provided, the results are considered acceptable if the view pane does not shatter, crack or become dislodged (as with the IEEE test).

Testing IR viewing windows with the metal cover in place is in conflict with the intent of the standard, since the crystal lens will shatter during the test. This renders the window ‘electrically unsafe’ because it fails the IP20 requirement that stipulates the largest allowable hole size in the cabinet is 13 mm. However, the window passes the test due to the fact that a steel rod of that diameter cannot be passed through the metal or plastic cover! If this standard is to be used to certify an IR window, then it is important to insist that the UL1558 test be completed with the covers open, and then meets the minimum test requirement by not shattering, cracking or dislodging, during or after the test.

When it comes to IR windows, the user needs to be more concerned with the mechanical stability of the windows, as a component within the switchgear assembly, and that it meets the minimum requirements for impact and load testing, rather than being misled that the window is somehow arc resistant.

For more information contact R&C Instrumentation, 086 111 4217, [email protected], www.randci.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Localised inverter-integrated transformer
Electrical Power & Protection
ACTOM, South Africa’s largest manufacturer, repairer and distributor of electromechanical equipment, is launching a breakthrough in renewable energy integration with its localised inverter-integrated transform

Read more...
Steinmüller Africa integrates advanced technologies at Mondi’s boiler project
Electrical Power & Protection
Steinmüller Africa is leading a boiler project at Mondi’s Richards Bay mill. The 18-month undertaking showcases the company’s blend of engineering excellence and cutting-edge technology.

Read more...
ABB innovation for energy efficiency and sustainability
Electrical Power & Protection
The application of sensor technology to reduce the operational and standby power losses of traditional current and voltage transformers can lead to energy savings of 181 MWh over a 30-year period, the lifetime of a typical switchboard in the African environment.

Read more...
UPS systems are key to keeping SA’s automotive industry up and running
Schneider Electric South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
During loadshedding, PLCs and OT systems often fail, not because they are directly tied to the factory’s core manufacturing process, but because they are now an integral part of IT infrastructure. When an IT system shuts down, the impact is far more complex than simply restarting machinery.

Read more...
ACTOM advances energy infrastructure
Electrical Power & Protection
At this critical juncture where South Africa is poised to modernise its power infrastructure, ACTOM’s Engineering Projects and Contracts (EPC) Division showcased its capabilities for the first time at Enlit Africa 2025.

Read more...
Advanced contactor solution to revolutionise motor management
Schneider Electric South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
Schneider Electric South Africa has launched the TeSys Deca Advanced, an advanced contactor solution designed to revolutionise motor management with unparalleled efficiency, reliability, simplicity and sustainability.

Read more...
Steaming ahead with boiler skills development
Electrical Power & Protection
As an expert in steam and boiler operations and maintenance, AES is very focused on safety, quality, technology advancement and the development of human capital. The company invests heavily in training and the promotion of talented people on an equal opportunity basis into the industrial operations environment.

Read more...
High-performance oscilloscopes
Electrical Power & Protection
RIGOL Technologies, a global leader in electronic measurement instruments, has launched two powerful additions to its oscilloscope portfolio.

Read more...
Revolutionising solar farm management with remote monitoring solutions
Electrical Power & Protection
As South Africa continues its transition to renewable energy, the efficient management of solar farms has become more critical than ever. Iritron, a leader in industrial automation and control systems, is at the forefront of this revolution, offering advanced remote monitoring solutions tailored to the unique challenges of solar farm operations.

Read more...
SKF announces wave energy technology partnership
SKF South Africa Electrical Power & Protection
SKF and Carnegie are collaborating on the design and delivery of a power take-off system driven by the motion of a buoy that sits a few metres below the surface of the ocean and moves with the ocean’s waves.

Read more...