IS & Ex


Fire extinguishing gas system sound issues

May 2015 IS & Ex

It is well documented that problems have occurred with hard disk drives when discharging gaseous fire extinguishing systems. Documented evidence exists for this problem, which can be attributed to all gas types.

Siemens has done extensive testing on gas systems and the hard drive issue, as have several other manufacturers and suppliers of fire protection equipment and hard disk ‘quality’ seems to be the root cause of the problem.

If one considers the length of time that gas fire extinguishing systems have been available and installed in data centres, you have to ask the question, why has the noise issue only surfaced in the last couple of years? What has actually changed?

Documented test results show that halocarbon agents such as Halon 1301 produce a higher sound level than inert gas blends. Inert gas blends took over from Halon 1301 some 20 years ago and design standards for these systems have remained basically unchanged for the last 10 years or so.

IT system technology, however, is changing on an almost daily basis and hard disk drives are no exception. There is a continued drive (pardon the pun) to increase data storage density and decrease data access times, while simultaneously reducing hardware costs. Many disk drives are now designed and produced in China with little or no vibration testing.

The collated international test data makes the following recommendations:

• Use enterprise-quality disks or solid-state disks where possible.

• Enclose hard disks in noise-proofed enclosures and keep the doors closed.

• Replicate critical data to offsite disk storage.

• Position siren and gas nozzle locations so that they do not radiate directly on the disk drives.

• Muzzle the sirens during fire-extinguisher tests.

• Increase the number and decrease the spacing of suppression nozzles to decrease their sound levels.

• Avoid very short discharge times (less than 60 seconds).

Overview of the problem

The noise level is proportional to the mass flow rate of the gas flowing through the discharge orifice. International consensus, backed up by testing, has shown that by increasing the number of nozzles or making discharge times longer, sound levels can be reduced.

When inert gasses were first introduced there was a concern that the discharge noise would be too high. Special sound reducing nozzles, incorporating a baffle, were introduced to combat the perceived problem. However, when testing was done, the discharge noise was 10 dB lower than a comparable Halon 1301 system and so the baffle nozzles were never commercialised.

There are several solutions that we have for reducing the noise level from the gas discharge. However, the gas discharge is not the root cause of the problem and one should be aware that disk faults have been caused just by the noise from the fire warning sirens or bells. A test conducted by an IT specialist and published on You-Tube shows disk errors occurring just by shouting at the disk drives!

The Alien Systems & Technologies solution

We recommend a two tier approach to mitigating the hard disk drive problem caused by sound:

1. IT specific:

• Use enterprise-quality disks or solid-state disks where possible.

• Enclose hard disks in noise-proofed enclosures, and keep the doors closed.

2. Fire system specific:

• Consider extending the discharge time to 2 minutes.

• Increase the number of discharge nozzles.

• Ensure nozzles do not point at server cabinets containing disk drives.

• Baffle the discharge nozzles.

Considering the fire specific points above, these are very easy to achieve with a Pyroshield system and an elegant solution is proposed as follows:

• The discharge time can be extended to 2 minutes by fitting a new orifice block. The effect of this is to reduce the mass flow rate to each nozzle by 50%.

• Increasing the number of discharge nozzles can be done with very minimal pipe layout changes. Doubling up on the number of nozzles would reduce the mass flow rate to each nozzle by 50%.

• A nozzle baffle is relatively easily implemented on the system. The baffle is simply fitted over the existing nozzles. Baffle holes will direct the discharge away from ceiling tiles and away from server cabinets.

However, IT specialists should understand that we are treating the symptom and not the cause, and the IT specific measures should also be implemented. As mechanical disk drives continue to become more and more sensitive due to performance and cost driven objectives, noise and vibration sensitivity will become more of an issue.

For more information contact Samantha Wright, Alien Systems & Technologies, +27 (0)11 949 1157, sam@astafrica.com, www.astafrica.com



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

The importance of up-to-date alarm annunciators
January 2020, Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists , IS & Ex
At 1.23 pm on Sunday, 24 July 1994, twenty-six people were injured when an explosion erupted through an oil refinery in an otherwise quiet corner of South Wales in the United Kingdom. The site was occupied ...

Read more...
Gas detector for multiple applications
January 2020, Comtest , IS & Ex
Comtest, the local representative of Industrial Scientific, global leader in gas detection, has announced a new version of the Ventis Slide-on Pump. The new pump is compatible with both Ventis MX4 and ...

Read more...
Light grid with integrated muting unit
November 2019, ifm - South Africa , IS & Ex
The new generation of light grids from ifm electronic allow for the muting mode without an external junction box or a muting relay being required, as they are already integrated into the receiving element. ...

Read more...
Light grid with integrated muting
October 2019, ifm - South Africa , IS & Ex
The new generation of light grids from ifm electronic incorporates muting mode without an external junction box or a muting relay being required, as they are already integrated into the receiving element. ...

Read more...
How integrated visual management and remote monitoring demystify machine safety
September 2019, Turck Banner , IS & Ex
This article shares common challenges for machine safety, and shows how combining easy-to-use safety devices with visual indication and remote monitoring capabilities can help make safety simpler and more effective.

Read more...
Security concerns for safety systems
September 2019, Phoenix Contact , IS & Ex
A common strategy required for the future.

Read more...
Taking safety to the next level
September 2019, SICK Automation Southern Africa , IS & Ex
SICK Automation is a world leading manufacturer of sensors, safety systems and automatic identification products. The next step for safety – this core idea therefore underpins the entire design of the ...

Read more...
Alarm system upgrade from Omniflex
September 2019, Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists , IS & Ex
Fiddler’s Ferry Power Station was constructed by the CEGB (Central Electricity Generating Board) in the UK and came into full operation in 1973. It has four 500 MW sets, giving a total generating capacity ...

Read more...
Intrinsic safety barcode scanning from Extech Safety Systems
September 2019, Extech Safety Systems , IS & Ex
Extech Safety Systems has worked with UK-based Mobexx to develop the MobXscan mobile application for barcode scanning with mobile devices. The app has been released for Windows 10 and Android, offering ...

Read more...
Smart devices for Ex areas
September 2019, Pepperl+Fuchs , IS & Ex
The Pepperl+Fuchs brand ecom has launched its next generation ATEX Zone 1/21 and Div. 1 certified, intrinsically safe 4G/LTE-Android smartphone – Smart-Ex. The Smart-Ex 02 is a complete new development ...

Read more...