System Integration & Control Systems Design


Reader feedback sent to Michael Brown

May 2014 System Integration & Control Systems Design

SA Instrumentation and Control contributing editor, Michael Brown, recently received some feedback on a loop optimisation article we published in the August 2013 edition. Since it is such a topical experience from a C&I engineer, we decided to publish it.

Mike,

I was reading your article in the August 2013 edition of SA Instrumentation and Control about strangely behaving valves and it reminded me of an experience I had when I was tuning a loop in a DMS plant. It was a simple loop controlling density with water flow, but I did not have a flowmeter to check the flow rates.

An I/P valve manufacturer had been issued with an order to provide a valve of a certain flow range that they did not have in stock, but they could modify the range of another valve by exchanging the seat. What they failed to do, however, was to recalibrate the valve for 4-20 mA: valve fully closed to fully open.

The valve only started opening above 8 mA and, since the loop was quite slow, this caused some problems as you will appreciate. Subsequently the project leader accused me of not knowing what I was doing, since the loop was not controlling the density satisfactorily. I stuck to my guns and said that the valve was not opening when it should.

I checked the density control later when I could open an outlet to see if there was water flowing, and sure enough there was no flow. Now it was my turn to make accusations about who had not done their job. Needless to say there were no apologies.

Regards,

Richard Mackay.



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Loop signature Part 2-4: Feedforward Control: Part 3
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
In the previous articles in this series, the basic theory behind feedforward control was discussed, and it was also shown how to apply feedforward in practice. In this article, it will be shown how well feedforward can work in practice by giving a couple of examples.

Read more...
Loop signature Part 2-3: Feedforward Control: Part 2
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Feedforward control tuning is not nearly as critical as feedback tuning, and fairly simple models are usually fine for the purpose in hand.

Read more...
PCS Global
PCS Global System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and industry: PCS Global led a digital infrastructure initiative in a southern African data centre setting, aiming to merge several essential operational systems into one cohesive platform. ...

Read more...
Seamless migration from ET 200M to ET 200SP HA for future-ready automation
Moore Process Controls System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and industry: Moore Process Controls undertook a modernisation initiative spanning the mining, petrochemical, and oil & gas sectors. This project involved upgrading legacy Siemens ET200M I/O ...

Read more...
Loop signature Part 2-2: Feedforward Control: Part 1
Michael Brown Control Engineering Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Feedforward control is a powerful technique that can dramatically improve control variance in cases where load changes cause big deviations from setpoint and the actual process dynamics are too slow to allow the feedback controller to operate fast enough to catch these disturbances.

Read more...
Proconics Modernises Refinery Tank Automation with Compliance-Focused, Brownfield Upgrades
Proconics System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project & Industry Proconics was engaged to modernise automation and SCADA systems across a refinery tank farm. The project involved complex brownfield integration, aligning new automation with existing ...

Read more...
Project & Industry
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project: Upgrading essential automation and SCADA systems at a coal mine.    Outcome: A modern, stable automation and SCADA environment with reduced technical debt and easier support, ready for expansion. ...

Read more...
Major digital transformation project for Isuzu Motors
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Isuzu Motors South Africa, in partnership with NoMuda and S4 Integration, has kicked off a major two-year digital transformation project to modernise its production environment.

Read more...
Loop Signature Part 2-1: Loop signatures and process transfer functions
Michael Brown Control Engineering Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The previous series of loop signature articles dealt with the basics of control loop optimisation, and concentrated on troubleshooting and ‘SWAG’ tuning of simple processes. In this new series, consideration will be given to dealing practically with more difficult issues like interactive processes, and with processes with much more complex dynamics.

Read more...
Modernising Vertical Filter Press Machines with Future-Focused Control Systems
Scibotron System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and Industry Pressure Filter Specialists approached us to modernise vertical filter press machines for the Minerals and Metals industry. The goal was to improve reliability, reduce downtime, ...

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved