System Integration & Control Systems Design


Reader feedback sent to Michael Brown

May 2014 System Integration & Control Systems Design

SA Instrumentation and Control contributing editor, Michael Brown, recently received some feedback on a loop optimisation article we published in the August 2013 edition. Since it is such a topical experience from a C&I engineer, we decided to publish it.

Mike,

I was reading your article in the August 2013 edition of SA Instrumentation and Control about strangely behaving valves and it reminded me of an experience I had when I was tuning a loop in a DMS plant. It was a simple loop controlling density with water flow, but I did not have a flowmeter to check the flow rates.

An I/P valve manufacturer had been issued with an order to provide a valve of a certain flow range that they did not have in stock, but they could modify the range of another valve by exchanging the seat. What they failed to do, however, was to recalibrate the valve for 4-20 mA: valve fully closed to fully open.

The valve only started opening above 8 mA and, since the loop was quite slow, this caused some problems as you will appreciate. Subsequently the project leader accused me of not knowing what I was doing, since the loop was not controlling the density satisfactorily. I stuck to my guns and said that the valve was not opening when it should.

I checked the density control later when I could open an outlet to see if there was water flowing, and sure enough there was no flow. Now it was my turn to make accusations about who had not done their job. Needless to say there were no apologies.

Regards,

Richard Mackay.



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Control system upgrade: Smelting
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Systems Automation & Management recently completed a major control system upgrade in the smelting industry. The project was delivered on budget and achieved a positive ROI for the client.

Read more...
Gottwald drives upgrade: Ports and harbours
Abacus Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
In the ports and harbours sector, Abacus Automation completed a significant modernisation of a Gottwald crane, improving both operational reliability and serviceability.

Read more...
Mining industry upgrade: From ageing systems to maximum capacity
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Iritron recently undertook a major upgrade in the mining sector, focusing on washing and screening plants, jigs, thickeners, tailings, water systems, conveyors and reclaimers.

Read more...
Agogo Integrated West Hub Project: FPSO/subsea offshore Angola
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The Agogo Integrated West Hub project represents a historic milestone in the FPSO and subsea industry, achieving first oil offshore of Angola. This project is the first FPSO deployment since ANPG’s establishment in 2019, and the first major project for Azule Energy since 2022.

Read more...
Case History 199: Another example of the effectiveness of cascade control
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
In my last article I wrote about how cascade control systems can effectively overcome valve problems. This article gives another example of how a temperature control was able to perform well, in spite of really severe valve problems.

Read more...
Digital transformation from the edge
DirectLogic Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
Edge-enabled PLCs are an accessible and affordable way for most users to collect and create value from use field-sourced data.

Read more...
Powering southern Africa’s industrial evolution for over five decades
Oilpower System Integration & Control Systems Design
Established in 1974, Oilpower is a recognised name in South Africa’s hydraulic and pneumatic sector. What started as a small, family-run business has matured into a highly structured operation with specialised teams, experienced engineers and a reputation for technical excellence and reliability. Oilpower is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year

Read more...
Case History 198: Cascade control overcomes valve problems
Michael Brown Control Engineering Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
A large petrochemical refinery asked me to perform an audit on several critical base layer control loops. This article deals with a problem found on a valve controlling the flow of fuel to a heat exchanger.

Read more...
Metal plant automation upgrade
ABB South Africa System Integration & Control Systems Design
A combined compressor house (CCH) control system replacement project, undertaken by NJC, an ABB Authorised Value Provider (AVP), has won high praise from client ArcelorMittal.

Read more...
Loop signature 28: Things to consider when tuning.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
I was giving a course at a remote mine in the middle of the Namibian desert. We were discussing tuning responses, and as I always do on my courses, I mentioned that in my opinion ¼ amplitude damped tuning is not desirable, and is in fact not good.

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved