Faulty positioner causes instability
Jan 2000
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Mimic Crafts
In a recent course held in a South African chemical plant, a loop was encountered that cycled continuously. The loop was a pressure control that was acting as the slave (secondary) loop in a cascade temperature control system on an oil heater. Figure 1 is a schematic of the control system. Repeated attempts had been made by the plant over an extended period of time to tune the loop to stop the cycling.
Figure 2 shows the closed loop test 'as found' performed by the class on the pressure loop. It can be seen that the loop cycled continuously with an amplitude of approximately 10% on the process variable (pressure signal). (The different changes in the test are where setpoint changes were made.)
The next test performed was in manual. Equal changes of 5% were made in the output of the controller as can be seen in Figure 3. The response on the process variable is very interesting. It can be seen that on every change the pressure seemed to 'overshoot' and then after some seconds slowly ramped back until it reached stability. A response like this is invariably due to a problem associated with the positioner, and sometimes also because the actuator of the valve has insufficient power to move the valve correctly, and the positioner then pumps too much air into the actuator to try and get the valve to move. Experience has shown that this type of response often causes complete instability in automatic mode.
In this particular case the resident plant 'valve expert' was called and the class went into the field with him, and inspected the valve. It was found that there was a problem with the positioner's feedback cam follower which was not moving freely. This was then adjusted. Figure 4 shows the next open loop test performed after fixing the problem. Note how well the process variable follows the controller output. The loop worked extremely well after tuning it correctly and putting it back in automatic.
This was yet another example of the need to analyse a loop first, before trying to tune it.
Further reading:
PCS Global
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and industry:
PCS Global led a digital infrastructure initiative in a southern African data centre setting, aiming to merge several essential operational systems into one cohesive platform.
...
Read more...
Seamless migration from ET 200M to ET 200SP HA for future-ready automation
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and industry:
Moore Process Controls undertook a modernisation initiative spanning the mining, petrochemical, and oil & gas sectors. This project involved upgrading legacy Siemens ET200M I/O
...
Read more...
Proconics Modernises Refinery Tank Automation with Compliance-Focused, Brownfield Upgrades
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project & Industry
Proconics was engaged to modernise automation and SCADA systems across a refinery tank farm. The project involved complex brownfield integration, aligning new automation with existing
...
Read more...
Project & Industry
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project: Upgrading essential automation and SCADA systems at a coal mine.
Outcome: A modern, stable automation and SCADA environment with reduced technical debt and easier support, ready for expansion.
...
Read more...
Major digital transformation project for Isuzu Motors
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Isuzu Motors South Africa, in partnership with NoMuda and S4 Integration, has kicked off a major two-year digital transformation project to modernise its production environment.
Read more...
Modernising Vertical Filter Press Machines with Future-Focused Control Systems
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and Industry
Pressure Filter Specialists approached us to modernise vertical filter press machines for the Minerals and Metals industry. The goal was to improve reliability, reduce downtime,
...
Read more...
Project & industry
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Project and Industry
This project involved delivering a complete electrical, instrumentation, and automation solution for a new OEM drum-twister machine, replacing an ageing unit in a major cabling production
...
Read more...
It’s a risky business not to challenge standard language
System Integration & Control Systems Design
On the surface, contracts all look alike. Once you’ve seen one, you’ve seen them all, or so it seems. Maybe so, but hidden within the standard language can be language that shifts the other party’s risk to you.
Read more...
Containerised Electrical & Control System Powers Paste Plant in Botswana
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Delivering a complete, containerized solution for a mine’s paste plant in Botswana, this project stands as a model of modern EC&I execution — integrating electrical, control, and automation systems into
...
Read more...
Control system upgrade: Smelting
SAM Systems Automation & Management
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Systems Automation & Management recently completed a major control system upgrade in the smelting industry. The project was delivered on budget and achieved a positive ROI for the client.
Read more...
printer friendly version