Faulty positioner causes instability
Jan 2000
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Mimic Crafts
In a recent course held in a South African chemical plant, a loop was encountered that cycled continuously. The loop was a pressure control that was acting as the slave (secondary) loop in a cascade temperature control system on an oil heater. Figure 1 is a schematic of the control system. Repeated attempts had been made by the plant over an extended period of time to tune the loop to stop the cycling.
Figure 2 shows the closed loop test 'as found' performed by the class on the pressure loop. It can be seen that the loop cycled continuously with an amplitude of approximately 10% on the process variable (pressure signal). (The different changes in the test are where setpoint changes were made.)
The next test performed was in manual. Equal changes of 5% were made in the output of the controller as can be seen in Figure 3. The response on the process variable is very interesting. It can be seen that on every change the pressure seemed to 'overshoot' and then after some seconds slowly ramped back until it reached stability. A response like this is invariably due to a problem associated with the positioner, and sometimes also because the actuator of the valve has insufficient power to move the valve correctly, and the positioner then pumps too much air into the actuator to try and get the valve to move. Experience has shown that this type of response often causes complete instability in automatic mode.
In this particular case the resident plant 'valve expert' was called and the class went into the field with him, and inspected the valve. It was found that there was a problem with the positioner's feedback cam follower which was not moving freely. This was then adjusted. Figure 4 shows the next open loop test performed after fixing the problem. Note how well the process variable follows the controller output. The loop worked extremely well after tuning it correctly and putting it back in automatic.
This was yet another example of the need to analyse a loop first, before trying to tune it.
Further reading:
Powering southern Africa’s industrial evolution for over five decades
Oilpower
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Established in 1974, Oilpower is a recognised name in South Africa’s hydraulic and pneumatic sector. What started as a small, family-run business has matured into a highly structured operation with specialised teams, experienced engineers and a reputation for technical excellence and reliability. Oilpower is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year
Read more...
Metal plant automation upgrade
ABB South Africa
System Integration & Control Systems Design
A combined compressor house (CCH) control system replacement project, undertaken by NJC, an ABB Authorised Value Provider (AVP), has won high praise from client ArcelorMittal.
Read more...
SIs - the channel’s conductors of light
Schneider Electric South Africa
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Today’s original equipment manufacturers are innovators in the truest sense, driving the absolute newest in technological advancement. While they develop advanced and often groundbreaking solutions, it is the system integrators who bring these innovations to life.
Read more...
The state of the SI industry remains strong and is expanding
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The system integration (SI) industry is expanding with the adoption of AI, automation and data sharing, allowing companies to improve operational efficiency and competitiveness across diverse sectors.
Read more...
The symbiotic relationship between OEMs and SIs
Schneider Electric South Africa
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
While businesses tend to turn directly to original equipment manufacturers OEMs or vendors when embarking on IT projects, the role of the SI as a key facilitator and partner cannot be overstated.
Read more...
Flexible and precise dispensing technology
Beckhoff Automation
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The Scheugenpflug ProcessModule axis system forms the basis of Atlas Copco’s dispensing and screwing cells and a flexible integration platform for general contractors and machine builders. Precise process sequences are ensured by TwinCAT CNC and servo drive technology from Beckhoff.
Read more...
The time is now for systems integrators
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
Integrators combine sophistication regarding technology innovation with practical, hands-on experience. Collaborating with systems integrators is the means to significant productivity improvement, powered by the convergence of automation and information and operations technology.
Read more...
System integrators are a diverse market
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
System integrators (SIs) combine expertise on emergent technologies with real world experience. Working with SIs, it’s inevitable that at some point someone will say, “We’re not a typical SI.” And in many ways, it’s true. SIs come in all shapes and sizes.
Read more...
Avoiding the pitfalls of PLC and scada control system integration
Iritron
System Integration & Control Systems Design
Upgrading your control system by integrating PLCs with scada systems should be a simple seamless process. Regrettably, the industry is plagued with control system integration and upgrade myths and misconceptions that can lead to liability issues, project delays, cost overruns and decreased plant performance.
Read more...
EtherCAT measurement terminals for vehicle development at Mercedes-Benz
Beckhoff Automation
System Integration & Control Systems Design
At the Mercedes Technology Centre plant in Sindelfingen, Germany, car axles are examined with the highest precision on four test benches, in parallel with road tests and simulations. All data is acquired using PC-based control from Beckhoff.
Read more...
printer friendly version