Editor's Choice

Innovating in the process industry with PLM

December 2017 Editor's Choice IT in Manufacturing

There is no doubt that with Industrie 4.0 there is a lot of innovation taking place in manufacturing IT. But ‘innovation’ is not only the creation of a new idea out of nothing, but more often the combination of two existing ideas in a new way to create something entirely new. For example, by combining a telephone, a music player, a camera and a GPS into a single smart device we create a range of new experiences and possibilities for communication, entertainment and travel. The value of the sum of the parts is more than that of the individual components.

Technology sharing across industries

The same thinking can be applied to IT solutions used in manufacturing. In one particular vertical industry a technology might have developed to maturity, and yet still be relatively invisible to another. This means that innovation is possible by simply applying the solutions from one industry in the other. In my consulting role, I have found that owing to industry specialisation surprisingly little experience is shared between vertical industries, and people tend to stick with the established techniques they know. There might be an opportunity for you to adopt a proven technique from another industry in a new way and thereby gain a competitive edge for your business in its own niche.

As industrial manufacturers face new challenges and opportunities arising from increased digitisation, many are looking to improve their existing MES architecture to support future strategic initiatives. Superficially they might refer to Industrie 4.0 as the driving force behind this change. But Industrie 4.0 is not a platform, it originated as an initiative in Germany to maintain and protect the competitiveness of the manufacturing sector. It cannot be purchased, nor implemented in the way an ERP solution might be, but rather describes a future of interconnected businesses involving cyber-physical systems, cloud computing, the Internet of Things and cognitive computing. This will manifest in many practical ways in your own business.

In the traditional vertical process industries such as oil and gas, chemicals, pulp and paper, and so on, the emphasis is on maximising the return on assets in capital intensive plants and minimising the cost of production of bulk commodity products. New product development, personalised products for customers and responsive supply chains are important, but in practice, these specific requirements are nowhere near as well developed as they are in fast moving discrete industries such as consumer goods, aerospace, etc.

The reality is that Industrie 4.0 will introduce increased volatility and change, and even the large commodity process companies will need to adapt. Is there then a technique we can learn, or a concept that we can take from the world of discrete manufacturing to apply in a process manufacturing plant that might provide a good foundation (or platform)? This will then create a more resilient business capable of responding to increasing volatility and change. In other words could we innovate in the world of process manufacturing by simply taking an existing IT solution from the world of discrete?

Product lifecycle management

In this regard, it might be worth taking a closer look at PLM (product lifecycle management). PLM originated to allow component manufacturers in the automotive supply chain to supply new products rapidly in response to the fast moving requirements of the motor manufacturers. PLM has since matured into a well established business process widely used in discrete manufacturing, but it is far less common in process manufacturing companies.

PLM tracks the lifecycle of each product from concept to design and engineering, manufacturing, quality and service management. A typical PLM environment is a formal system of collaboration to enable rapid product development and engineering, portfolio management, technical data management, service management and continuous improvement. These processes are supported by a governance and compliance layer that ensures that changes are controlled, approved and in line with the requirements of legislation and the companies own standards.

The adoption of PLM in process manufacturing has been slower than in discrete manufacturing owing to the intrinsic nature of their asset intensive operations.

A chemicals plant might have a few dozen products at most, and sell these in high volumes to relatively few customers. Historically there was little need for customisation in such a scenario, and a dedicated plant will typically make a single product to specification. The product is generally produced to stock.

In contrast, discrete industries have high numbers of personalised products which are generally made to order. The complexity of managing a large portfolio of these unique products requires significant collaboration across multiple disciplines including development, engineering, sales and service. This collaboration platform is potentially of interest to a process company facing a much more complex and dynamic challenge as Industrie 4.0 takes hold across the industry.

A PLM solution is far more than a simple document management system with workflows. PLM systems support the process of inception, design and engineering, right through to real-world monitoring. The whole value chain is modelled through the product lifecycle allowing for optimisation across multiple disciplines and organisational function/departments.

The future manufacturing environment described by Industrie 4.0 is a dynamic one, where information flows alongside physical product. The pace of change will be significant, not only in the actual product requirements, but also in raw materials, pricing, regulatory requirements, territories and so on. Furthermore, service levels will become more complex to maintain as customers demand more unique and personalised supply contracts. The impact of these dynamic and fast moving changes on the core manufacturing value chain should really be managed by a platform that is much better than the existing disconnected ‘electronic scraps of paper’ found in most companies.

Gavin Halse

Gavin Halse is a chemical process engineer who has been involved in the manufacturing sector since mid-1980. He founded a software business in 1999 which grew to develop specialised applications for mining, energy and process manufacturing in several countries. Gavin is most interested in the effective use of IT in industrial environments and now consults part time to manufacturing and software companies around the effective use of IT to achieve business results.

For more information contact Gavin Halse, Absolute Perspectives, +27 (0)83 274 7180, gavin@gavinhalse.com, www.absoluteperspectives.com


Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Loop Signatures 10: Digital controllers – Part 2: Testing controller operation
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice
There is a commonly held belief in control circles that all PID controllers are similar and relatively simple. This is a dangerous fallacy.

A review of the 2021 MESA Africa conference
MESA Africa NPC Editor's Choice
The overarching lesson from this year’s conference: yes, we have problems now and solutions are on the table, but we need collective action!

Cybersecurity for operational technology: Part 5: Cybersecurity threats to critical information infrastructure.
Editor's Choice
CII describes infrastructure that is essential to the functioning of a country’s society and economy(2). Local examples include energy (Eskom), government (SARS, judiciary), police and defence (SAPS, ...

The ultimate control valve
Valve & Automation Valves, Actuators & Pump Control Editor's Choice
Zwick has designed its TRI-SHARK range of Triple Eccentric Valves to be used in control or throttling applications as well as for pure on/off functionality.

From the editor's desk: 2022 must be the year SA gets its vaccination act together
Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control) Editor's Choice News
This is his last "From the editor's desk" that Steven Meyer wrote before his death in early January 2022.

What to do when fragmented systems get too complex
Absolute Perspectives Editor's Choice
With proper planning, a strategic approach, careful vendor selection and a systematic project methodology, you can successfully upgrade to a future-proof ICT infrastructure that supports ongoing digital transformation.

Case History 180: Fuel gas pressure control problem
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice
The problem with the pressure control was that it seemed to work intermittently and seldom got to setpoint, resulting in large and unacceptable variance on the control.

Cybersecurity for operational technology: Part 4: Practical recommendations to reduce cybersecurity risks for OT systems
Wolfpack Information Risk Editor's Choice
It is essential that IT professionals are able to clearly articulate cybersecurity risks to management.

Loop Signatures 9: Digital controllers – Part 1: Introduction to the simple PID controller
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice
There is a commonly held belief in control circles that all PID controllers are similar and relatively simple. This is a dangerous fallacy.

Totally Integrated Automation – added value in three dimensions
Siemens South Africa Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
Discover everything that’s in TIA, the leading automation concept from Siemens, and how it all works together to create a unique product for machine builders and industrial enterprises.