System Integration & Control Systems Design


The unified enterprise (Part 3) - business IT and shopfloor IT

June 2006 System Integration & Control Systems Design

Having got the technology hurdle out of the way, it is time to consider the human aspect of enterprise integration in respect of business IT and shop floor IT.

In Part 2, we saw the different information needs of business and production processes and how they could be reconciled through existing application framework `filters' and the use of standards such as ISA-95.

Traditionally, IT managers have paid as much attention to the realtime complexities of the shopfloor as the rest of us paid to root canal. As the shopfloor got itself better organised and historians became the repositories of vast quantities of mission-critical information, CEOs started to wonder why they were running two information departments. And the instrumentation engineer started to wonder why he was beginning to understand what his IT colleague was talking about.

In the 1960s and '70s, we had data processing managers running data processing departments. Those were names given to a breed of individuals who understood computers while everyone else stood around in awe - Stonehenge, high priests, peasants - same sort of thing. Data processing personnel were not only required to look after the roomfuls of hardware but were also responsible for developing business software that would allow the company to run its business processes more effectively. But today, almost everyone understands computers and how to beat them into submission and we have more commercially available software solutions than we can handle. No more mystery there, so a limited future for the high priests. Instead, they became information technology experts but often with the focus on technology rather than information. In other words, nothing much had changed.

The instrumentation engineer's job changed the very instant someone else wanted to know what he did within the grander scheme of things. He suddenly realised that optimising P&IDs had no meaning if they did not help the company achieve its business objectives. In order to contribute to this, he saw that he needed to change his role from instrumentation engineer to information provider. For the sake of efficiency, profitability and competitiveness, it became necessary to take a more formal approach towards the gathering and compilation of realtime information and to reconcile it with that of traditional business systems. Only in this way could manufacturing execution systems (MES) become a reality.

Today, we have a situation where realtime data repositories can eclipse those of business IT systems in sheer magnitude, scope and criticality. The shopfloor now has disaster recovery and change management solutions to automatically back up and diagnose releases of HMI, PLC and robotic software. By definition, the instrumentation engineer has become a high priest of data processing because he knows things other people do not. This has angered the 'traditional' high priests of data processing because they are no longer in complete control of the company's total information needs. Yet, these same high priests are not comfortable working in the realtime environment where masses of data are needed on a millisecond time scale. Invoicing, after all, is based on a calendar rather than a stopwatch.

So, today, we have companies with what amounts to two IT departments - one in charge of making the money (production) and the other in charge of managing it (traditional business IT). The information pipeline that connects the two can be as thick or as thin as needed and the filters at either end of this pipeline are defined by international standards like ISA-95.

Two IT departments means another kid on the block and that means that the first kid is not going to like it. Unifying a company's information requirements into a seamless asset is going to affect at least four groups of people:

The instrumentation engineer

Being an information supplier in charge of, often, more than half of the company's total information assets, rarely formed part of his/her job description. While mucking about with computers can be fun (?) diagnosing processes and improving them is often a lot more rewarding. So, mister instrument engineer, you should be allowed to exercise your process skills while you should consider getting some help from your traditional IT department which is well versed in the management of information and its infrastructure.

The IT manager

While millisecond response times and realtime diagnostic procedures may not be what you are used to, they are not your problem. Let the people who know about these things handle them. Instead, you bring a wealth of knowledge to the management of information and you should lend your instrumentation colleague a hand.

The scada solution vendor

Scada solution suppliers have been caught with their alarms blaring because many still think that scada somehow operates outside the ambit of business information provision. Pipelines to scada data are next to useless. Pipelines to scada information are far more useful. But data is transformed into information by applications and, since there is more than one application vendor on the planet, they are going to have to conform to information exchange standards such as ISA-95.

The CEO

Because of their vastly different functions, two information repositories are probably inevitable because they each have quite different operating specifications. This is not a duplication of assets but rather a step closer to having a unification of information assets geared to providing factual information, cause and effect scenarios and performance measurement facilities that will keep your finger on the pulse of your organisation.

One solution that has been tried and seems to work well for reconciling the differences between the two IT departments, is to create the position of chief information officer (or similar) to whom both the business IT manager and the control and instrumentation engineer report. As to scada solution vendors, they see the future lie with moving further 'North' into the manufacturing execution systems arena as they change to meet customer needs for compatible information solutions.

With this unified information structure, chief executives and management should also start getting used to the idea of change because this new approach will revolutionise accounting and enterprise-wide costing, performance management and personnel recognition.

In Part 4, we see the vital role that manufacturing execution systems play at the core of the enterprise's information network.

For more information contact Justin Tweedie, Futuristix, 0861 WONDER (0861 966 337), [email protected], www.futuristix.co.za





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

The state of the SI industry remains strong
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The system integration (SI) industry is expanding with the adoption of AI, automation and data sharing, allowing companies to improve operational efficiency and competitiveness across diverse sectors.

Read more...
The symbiotic relationship between OEMs and SIs
Schneider Electric South Africa Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
While businesses tend to turn directly to original equipment manufacturers OEMs or vendors when embarking on IT projects, the role of the SI as a key facilitator and partner cannot be overstated.

Read more...
Flexible and precise dispensing technology
Beckhoff Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
The Scheugenpflug ProcessModule axis system forms the basis of Atlas Copco’s dispensing and screwing cells and a flexible integration platform for general contractors and machine builders. Precise process sequences are ensured by TwinCAT CNC and servo drive technology from Beckhoff.

Read more...
The time is now for systems integrators
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
Integrators combine sophistication regarding technology innovation with practical, hands-on experience. Collaborating with systems integrators is the means to significant productivity improvement, powered by the convergence of automation and information and operations technology.

Read more...
System integrators are a diverse market
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
System integrators (SIs) combine expertise on emergent technologies with real world experience. Working with SIs, it’s inevitable that at some point someone will say, “We’re not a typical SI.” And in many ways, it’s true. SIs come in all shapes and sizes.

Read more...
Avoiding the pitfalls of PLC and scada control system integration
Iritron System Integration & Control Systems Design
Upgrading your control system by integrating PLCs with scada systems should be a simple seamless process. Regrettably, the industry is plagued with control system integration and upgrade myths and misconceptions that can lead to liability issues, project delays, cost overruns and decreased plant performance.

Read more...
EtherCAT measurement terminals for vehicle development at Mercedes-Benz
Beckhoff Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
At the Mercedes Technology Centre plant in Sindelfingen, Germany, car axles are examined with the highest precision on four test benches, in parallel with road tests and simulations. All data is acquired using PC-based control from Beckhoff.

Read more...
Loop signature 23: Tuning Part 2.
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
It is my opinion that most tuning methods are very crude. They do of course also offer a starting point for tuning if one is not fortunate enough to have a sophisticated tuning package like a Protuner around.

Read more...
PIC microcontrollers with integrated FPGA features in TME
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The new PIC16F131xx microcontrollers in TME’s offering from Microchip are ideal for the evolving and miniaturising electronic equipment market, offering efficient power management and predictable response times for controllers.

Read more...
Five smart machine trends you need to know
Adroit Technologies System Integration & Control Systems Design
The last ten years have brought about dramatic advances in technologies that OEMs had never realised would affect their designs or the saleability of their machines, much less impact business models and profits so dramatically. The following discussion will cover key advancements and recommendations all OEMs should be adopting in their design processes to stay current and competitive.

Read more...