The editorial team at SA Instrumentation and control is always delighted when we receive feedback in the form of letters to the editor. So, when control loop expert and resident SAI&C contributing editor Michael Brown received this feedback from an automation engineer in Australia, we thought it was worth publishing together with the response.
Dear Michael,
I was re-reading this Case Study 127 on ‘Severe control problems in the mining industry’ and was overcome by chagrin – otherwise known as a bad case of ‘head-in-hands’ syndrome.
I am the senior automation engineer for a Mining OEM here in Australia, and I have to acknowledge the truth of almost every point in your article. Except, perhaps, for the last one around understanding and correctly configuring the PLC controllers, I like to think I have that one in hand.
I'd love to copy this Case Study to our Tech Services team - but I think you understand what kind of reception that would get!
Thanks anyhow for a good laugh.
Cheers,
Philip Wilkie.
Hi Philip,
I enjoyed receiving your email. I am pleased you found the article relevant.
Just want to mention that I find that controllers are set up incorrectly in at least 85% of all the many plants I go into that use PLC systems for regulatory control, so that scientific tuning is very often impossible. In two extreme cases, the system integrators did not like the standard PID block in the PLC software and wrote their own algorithms, which didn’t work at all. One of these plants ran for 10 years with all its controllers in manual! This was one of the biggest platinum concentrators in South Africa.
I can give you lots of examples of bad cases of ‘head-in-hands’ syndrome. I actually now find it hard holding up my head unsupported.
Read more...From the editor's desk: Consistently not stupid Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control)
News
Over the years I’ve followed Charlie Munger. He’s considered to be one of the greatest investors and thinkers on decision making in the past century, and spent six decades as Warren Buffett’s business ...
Read more...South Africa’s space balls
Editor's Choice News
South African engineers are preparing to take low-frequency radio astronomy to the Moon with three locally developed B.A.L.L.S. spheres aboard China’s Chang’e-8 mission. This could pave the way for a 55-antenna lunar array and marks another step in the country’s growing space engineering capability.
Read more...RS South Africa announces 2026 Student Project Fund winners RS South Africa
News
RS South Africa has awarded 13 engineering students with R10?000 worth of products each through its 2026 Student Project Fund, supporting projects spanning renewable energy, robotics, warehouse automation and STEM education.
Read more...Certified gas meter module
News
Sensirion’s next-generation SGM5304 gas meter module has completed certification to the harmonised EN 17526 standard, simplifying MID approval and speeding customers’ route to market.
Read more...Trafo Power Solutions expands market share
News
Trafo Power Solutions is expanding its market share in mining, industrial, infrastructure, data centre and renewable energy applications through technical expertise, application-specific engineering and responsive customer support.
Read more...Trafo Power Solutions returns to Electra Mining Africa
News
Trafo Power Solutions returns to Electra Mining Africa 2026 with a portfolio that has expanded well beyond dry-type transformers into fully engineered electrical power solutions for mining, industrial and infrastructure operations across Africa.
While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.
printer friendly version