Editor's Choice


If a machine can do it, why not learn something else?

April 2018 Editor's Choice

By the end of 2017, The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) reported an estimated 60 000 imports of multipurpose industrial robots into Africa. From a South African perspective, the dominant sectors in multipurpose industrial robot adoption are the mining and automotive industries. This is in line with global figures (automotive occupying 35% share of the robotic market), published by the International Federation of Robotics (IFR) in the World Robotics 2017 report. The mining situation in South Africa closely mirrors that of Botswana, where robots are now employed to minimise safety risks in the recovery of diamonds at depths that impose safety risks to humans.

This rapidly growing automation trend in the form of robotics has instilled fear in the minds of many Africans, and more so, South Africans. At the core of this anxiety is the fear of the unknown with regards to employment opportunities and employability, based on current skill sets. However, many other people are excited about this development as it cultivates the belief that it will resuscitate the currently sluggish aggregate demand.

Consequently, the epistemological thought that inextricably holds my imagination, gave rise to the question: “If a machine can do it, why learn it, why not learn something else?” At the World Economic Forum in January 2018, Jack Ma, who was ranked second in the annual ‘World’s 50 Greatest Leaders’ by multinational business magazine Fortune, in 2017, made a profound remark. He postulated: “We need to teach our kids things robots cannot do. If a robot can do it, we need to think twice.”

At the core of their education, young and future professionals must integrate human constructs that are antithetical to the phenomenon of robots. There are plenty of these, but this article focuses on two, namely:

Creativity, innovation and entrepreneurialism

Poetry, music, painting, drawing, dancing etc. are all arts that tap into innate human talents and deepened practice (formal and informal) of these activities has proven to be linked to what people term ‘innovation and creativity’. Robots, at least for now, cannot innovate and by their nature are not authentically creative.

Inherent human constructs

Values, empathy, collaboration through emotional connection to others, teamwork, independent thinking, critical analysis, persistence, influencing, and leadership etc. are constructs that robots, at least the current generation, cannot learn.

On reflection, where can one learn these constructs? In our basic education program in South Africa, when you harness the talents, skills, and resources of other learners, it is called cheating. In the workplace it is called leadership (i.e. using your network). People who did this in school were called cheaters. In life, they are called ‘connected’, ‘resourceful’ or ‘leaders’. Perhaps it’s a work vs education antithesis? This is something to ponder on going forward.

To conclude on this robot-human discourse, it is my belief that learning the above-mentioned human constructs, along with many other skills, will ease the ‘rivalry’ between humans and robots, and will lead to a more complementary approach between the two species.

Oratile Sematle

Oratile is the Electrical and Instrumentation manager at Sasol Group Technology. He holds a bachelor of science degree in electrical and electronic engineering as well an MBA from the University of Cape Town. As the former president of the Society of Automation, Instrumentation, Measurement and Control (SAIMC), he helps to drive the vision shared by council to address issues specific to the automation industry, and is partly accountable for the development of the automation engineering profession in South Africa. Oratile is a conference speaker and has spoken at engineering events such as Industry 4.0 and African Automation Fair. His ambition is to form cross-industry coalitions to tackle the social and educational problems experienced by disadvantaged communities.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

How to size and select a servo motor
Festo South Africa Editor's Choice Motion Control & Drives
Festo highlights some factors to consider in the process of sizing and selecting a servo motor effectively to ensure optimal performance, reliability and energy efficiency.

Read more...
Dynamic control of industrial solar plants and energy storage systems
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Electrical Power & Protection
Spanish Group, Power Electronics has demonstrated its comprehensive expertise in sustainable energy supply in over 3000 solar and energy storage projects with a total installed capacity of 120 GW. To control its modular systems, the company relies on open, high-performance Beckhoff control technology.

Read more...
Loop signature Part 2-4: Feedforward Control: Part 3
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
In the previous articles in this series, the basic theory behind feedforward control was discussed, and it was also shown how to apply feedforward in practice. In this article, it will be shown how well feedforward can work in practice by giving a couple of examples.

Read more...
Engineers, AI and the risk of cognitive surrender
Editor's Choice
AI will have a significant impact on how engineering work gets done in the future, but the cognitive implications of continued AI use are serious.

Read more...
Reinventing grain silo management
VEGA Controls SA Editor's Choice
The VEGAPULS 6X radar sensor is designed for continuous level measurement to help overcome the challenges faced by storage in grain silos.

Read more...
Trends in humanoid robots
Editor's Choice
Humanoid robots are increasingly viewed less as futuristic prototypes and more as a practical route to bring artificial intelligence into human-designed environments.

Read more...
Four futures for AI: The choices we need to make now
Editor's Choice IT in Manufacturing
AI is everywhere and its implications are now structural. The question is no longer whether AI will matter, but what kind of society it will shape.

Read more...
Modular control platform for the hydrogen industry
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Electrical Power & Protection
With a seamless modular control solution from Beckhoff featuring over 500 data points and numerous ELX series terminals with intrinsically safe interfaces, Greenlight Innovation is breaking new ground in hydrogen testing.

Read more...
Loop signature Part 2-3: Feedforward Control: Part 2
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Feedforward control tuning is not nearly as critical as feedback tuning, and fairly simple models are usually fine for the purpose in hand.

Read more...
Proactive treatment of industrial boiler water
Editor's Choice
As water treatment is a critical aspect of industrial boiler management and potentially one of the greatest operational risk points, AES relies on close partnerships with third-party industrial water treatment specialists. These act as important safety nets.

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved