The first example is that of a flow control loop on a liquid flow. Figure 1 shows a closed loop test with a step change of setpoint.
Figure 1.
Three problems immediately stand out:
1. The tuning is terribly slow.
2. The valve is sticking badly. It takes a long time to move then sticks several more times as it opens.
3. The valve is probably extremely oversized which can be seen by the huge step in PV as compared with small step in the controller output.
Figure 2 shows the open loop stepping test. This confirms deductions 2 and 3 made from the closed loop test. In particular it shows that the valve is at least 7 times oversized. In addition another extremely serious problem has been uncovered, namely that the valve overshoots really badly, particularly in the closing direction, and the positioner takes an extremely long period to correct the overshoot. These factors make good control almost impossible.
Figure 2.
This is confirmed in Figure 3 which is closed loop and shows a setpoint step change made with much better tuning, which was kept as slow as possible to try and overcome the problems of sticking and overshoot. However, it did not help as the valve stuck and then hugely overshot. The controller tried to bring it back, but the same thing happened in reverse and the valve is now in what could be described as a terribly slow stick-slip cycle.
Figure 3.
Problems on a pressure control loop
The second example is an interesting pressure control loop. The operators were always complaining about this loop, which they had to try and control in manual as it did not control in automatic.
A closed loop test with the existing tuning parameters was tried, but nothing seemed to happen when a setpoint step change was made. Very fortunately there was a flowmeter in series with the valve, which allowed us to examine the valve performance. The open loop stepping test showing the flow versus the controller output is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4.
The following extremely serious valve problems were revealed:
1. There is no valve movement until the controller output gets above 30%.
2. The valve is very sticky.
3. When making the same size steps on the controller output the valve response is very erratic and non-repeatable with big movements in some places, and small in others. At times it didn’t move at all. This makes any reasonable control impossible.
However, further testing of the actual pressure loop showed it to have extremely slow dynamics, and in fact crude but reasonable pressure control was obtained, by running the loop with “ON/OFF” control, that is with the valve either fully open or closed. This is equivalent to controlling the temperature in a bath, as opposed to “throttling” control when controlling the temperature of a shower.
Michael Brown is a specialist in control loop optimisation with many years of experience in process control instrumentation. His main activities are consulting, and teaching practical control loop analysis and optimisation. He gives training courses which can be held in clients’ plants, where students can have the added benefit of practising on live loops. His work takes him to plants all over South Africa and also to other countries. He can be contacted at Michael Brown Control Engineering cc, +27 (0)82 440 7790, [email protected], www.controlloop.co.za
Read more...A cure for measurement headaches in contract manufacturing VEGA Controls SA
Editor's Choice
A contract manufacturing organisation provides support to pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies in the manufacturing of medications, formulations and substances. VEGA’s measurement solutions offer accuracy and reliability for monitoring levels and pressures during the manufacturing process.
Read more...PC-based control for a food capsule and pod packaging machine Beckhoff Automation
Editor's Choice
For TME, a machine builder specialising in the packaging of powdered foods, Beckhoff’s PC-based control technology offers unlimited opportunities when it comes to performance and innovative capacity in terms of flexibility, scalability and openness.
Read more...Case History 198: Cascade control overcomes valve problems Michael Brown Control Engineering
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
A large petrochemical refinery asked me to perform an audit on several critical base layer control loops. This article deals with a problem found on a valve controlling the flow of fuel to a heat exchanger.
Read more...Simple and efficient level measurement in the mining, minerals and metals industries Endress+Hauser South Africa
Editor's Choice Level Measurement & Control
Measuring devices in the mining, minerals and metals industries face the challenge of varying material states and long distances in measurement height. Endress+Hauser’s answer to these challenges is the new Micropilot family.
Read more...PC-based control for fertiliser Beckhoff Automation
Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
On a farm in the USA, valuable ammonia is extracted from slurry and processed into ammonium sulphate. NSI Byosis has transformed this complex process into a flexible modular system. This modular approach requires an automation solution with flexible scalability in both hardware and software, which this Dutch company has found in PC-based control from Beckhoff.
Read more...Loop signature 28: Things to consider when tuning. Michael Brown Control Engineering
Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
I was giving a course at a remote mine in the middle of the Namibian desert. We were discussing tuning responses, and as I always do on my courses, I mentioned that in my opinion ¼ amplitude damped tuning is not desirable, and is in fact not good.
Read more...Control without complexity
Editor's Choice Motion Control & Drives
In an era where precision, performance and smart control define industrial success, the right driver can make all the difference. At Axiom Hydraulics, we’ve seen firsthand how the Sun Hydraulics XMD series transforms hydraulic systems, from mining and construction to agriculture and automation.
Read more...The thermal combustion balancing act
Editor's Choice
From carbon taxes to export tariffs, and cost containment to security of supply and sustainability, companies are under increasing pressure to switch to greener fuel sources. Associated Energy Services warns that this pivotal change has some potentially serious knock-on effects.
Read more...What’s driving the IE3 motor revolution? WEG Africa
Editor's Choice
The International Efficiency 3 (IE3) motor standard will soon become South Africa’s legal minimum standard, mandating that local suppliers offer more efficient electric motors. What is driving this change, and how does it affect the many industries that rely on these modern electric workhorses?
printer friendly version