IT in Manufacturing


Device level Ethernet requires careful network selection

August 2011 IT in Manufacturing

As the market for industrial Ethernet at the device level continues to expand and the technology itself continues to develop, so too do the value propositions the network offers to its growing base of constituents. Ethernet as a platform for horizontal and vertical integration remains a significant driver behind continued growth. However, the stark contrast between using Ethernet as an integration platform versus a control network serving machine, motion, or process control provides an indication of the growing range of potential applications – and iterations.

While the high-level industrial Ethernet value propositions of faster data rates, greater bandwidth and leveraging of largely COTS technology cross applications, the application disparities reduce the prospects for commonality, limiting ultimate business benefit. For example, while in some plants and factories the goal is to use industrial Ethernet as a horizontal and vertical integration platform, this is not practical for those who maintain a tiered approach to industrial networks.

ARC’s previous analyses of the market for Ethernet at the device level highlighted the benefits associated with Ethernet’s commonality versus openness. This prospect remained true in our most recently completed report, especially for customers focused on using industrial Ethernet as a platform for horizontal and vertical integration. Manufacturers focused on Ethernet as an integration platform are typically more oriented toward use of a single common network to integrate all aspects of the enterprise, from control, to security/surveillance, to logistics, with transparent networking via TCP/IP and concurrently running protocols. In these applications, industrial Ethernet eases and speeds system integration through the widespread availability and commonality of networked devices, COTS-based tools, ongoing development, standardisation and knowledgeable personnel.

This potential benefit may be less important, however, to an OEM machine builder more focused on Ethernet-based real-time motion control solutions. These may employ common COTS-based tools and physical media, but displace TCP/IP with a real-time messaging protocol and use a gateway to interface the machine to a higher level factory network.

Motion control networks are a different breed

The fast growing, real-time motion/machine control segment leverages Ethernet’s features to achieve a performance leap over traditional serial device networks. Additional benefits, such as combined control and engineering design, installation savings and remote diagnostics and maintenance are also available.

Motion control applications leverage commercial Ethernet’s increasing bandwidth and data rates. But at the drive bus level, the network must also be able to coordinate multiple axes and feedback devices with the master controller. The reality is that many Ethernet-based motion control networks are implemented as drive or motion subnetworks that replace the TCP/IP portion of the stack with their own messaging interface or subvert it to the motion bus. These networks then interface to the larger factory network via a gateway.

Consequently, in these instances the Ethernet value proposition is primarily derived from the lower level of the stack as well as from use of COTS tools. Devices on the motion control network typically cannot interface directly to the Ethernet-based factory network or any other industrial Ethernet network. In this application space, it is not unusual to find homogenous, single-vendor networks with few if any third-party devices, even when the ‘standard’ Ethernet-based motion control networks are used. And, similar to the experience with serial device networks, we find that customers are purchasing and installing OEM machinery without even realising that it contains an Ethernet-based machine control bus.

Process automation lags discrete and motion control

Process automation is another industrial segment in which Ethernet adoption at the device level is a current topic of discussion. Ethernet is well established at the control level in the process world and is just now starting to make its way into the field. These applications are typically in non-hazardous areas and take advantage of Ethernet’s broad bandwidth to communicate process values from high-end, multivariable instrumentation. We expect the data acquisition (versus control) aspect of this segment increasingly to adopt industrial Ethernet and present its own distinct set of application requirements, further fragmenting the industrial Ethernet landscape.

The industrial Ethernet market is dividing into distinct sectors that reflect distinct value propositions across the total available market. Continued incremental additions in areas such as time synchronisation, functional or machine safety, energy management and embedded switching, among others, further differentiate the available industrial protocol offerings. ARC’s recently completed study, Industrial Ethernet-Based Devices Worldwide Outlook (www.arcweb.com/res/ethernet), assists customers in selecting the right industrial Ethernet solution for the target task.

For more information on contact Paul Miller, ARC Advisory Group, +1 781 471 1126, [email protected], www.arcweb.com





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Looking into the future of machine vision
Omron Electronics IT in Manufacturing
Artificial intelligence (AI) is driving a significant transformation in all areas of industrial automation, and machine vision is no exception. Omron’s AI-powered machine vision systems seamlessly integrate state-of-the-art algorithms, enabling machines to analyse and interpret visual data meticulously.

Read more...
Driving digital transformation in the truck industry
Siemens South Africa IT in Manufacturing
Tatra Trucks, a leading truck manufacturer in Czechia, has adopted the Siemens Xcelerator portfolio of industry software including Teamcenter software for product lifecycle management and the Mendix low code platform to help increase production volume and strengthen its ability to manufacture vehicles that meet specific customer requirements.

Read more...
Opinion piece: Digital twins in manufacturing – design, optimise and expand
Schneider Electric South Africa IT in Manufacturing
Digital twin technology can help create better products, fast. It can also transform the work of product development. This strong statement from McKinsey reinforces how far digital twins have come in manufacturing.

Read more...
Asset tracking is key to driving operational excellence and sustainable growth
Schneider Electric South Africa IT in Manufacturing
Asset tracking plays a critical role in the success of industrial businesses. By effectively managing and monitoring assets, companies can optimise their operations, ensuring that resources are used efficiently. This leads to improved productivity and reduced costs.

Read more...
Siemens democratises AI-driven PCB design for small and medium electronics teams
Siemens South Africa IT in Manufacturing
Siemens Digital Industries Software is making its AI-enhanced electronic systems design technology more accessible to small and mid-sized businesses with PADS Pro Essentials software and Xpedition Standard software.

Read more...
Predicting and preventing cyber-attacks with AI and generative AI
IT in Manufacturing
The speed at which cyber threats are evolving is unprecedented. As a result, companies need to implement state-of-the-art technology to protect their data and systems.

Read more...
Real-world lessons in digital transformation
IT in Manufacturing
Synthesis has helped businesses across multiple industries with their digital transformation by solving their unique integration challenges.

Read more...
Enhancing cyber security for industrial drives
Siemens South Africa IT in Manufacturing
The growing connection between production networks and office networks as part of IT/OT integration and the utilisation of IoT have many benefits for industrial companies. At the same time, they also increase the risk of cyber threats. Siemens ensures that your know-how and plants are protected at all times.

Read more...
Immersion cooling systems for data centres
IT in Manufacturing
The demand for data centres in Africa is growing. The related need for increasing rack densities brings with it escalating cooling requirements.

Read more...
Transforming pulp and paper with automation and digitalisation
ABB South Africa IT in Manufacturing
The pulp and paper industry in South Africa is undergoing a significant transformation from traditional manual processes to embracing automation technologies. Automation in pulp and paper mills aims to improve various production stages, from raw material preparation to final product creation.

Read more...