Motion Control & Drives


Linear actuator drive selection

April 2018 Motion Control & Drives

Designing an automated system requiring any type of linear motion is no easy task. Selecting the correct technology behind the actuator really depends upon what the designer wants to accomplish with it. Like much in engineering, making the right selection is less about focusing on a single characteristic than finding a good balance of performance from a number of different factors. Costly mistakes can be avoided by weighing up the available options analytically while designing efficient and economical motion control systems.

The majority of electromechanical linear actuators are comprised of five common types of drive trains: ball screws, lead screws, timing belts, rack-and-pinion tracks and linear motors. Understanding the strengths and limitations of each type and weighing them against the design requirements is the most logical approach. After all, linear actuators can be used in a wide variety of applications, from automated packaging lines and pick-and-place operations to complex machines such as 3D printers, which require precision positioning accuracy.

The most common drive train types

In linear motion, drive trains offer a dual function. They are primarily used for repetitive positioning and therefore need to provide acceptable accuracy and repeatability (the ability to back to the same commanded position repeatedly) according to the purpose for which they are required. At the same time, they apply force over distance, which requires them to possess sufficient tensile strength.

Ball screws, a popular and widely used drive train consists of a threaded rod and matched ball nut with ball bearings between the nut and screw surfaces. Ball screws are an ideal solution for high duty cycle applications, as well as applications requiring high force density, precision and repeatability. The rolling ball bearings reduce friction and provide high mechanical efficiency, even when in constant use. They can achieve moderate speed.

Lead screws consist of a threaded rod and matching threaded nut sliding interface surfaces. They are suitable for low duty cycle applications, or applications requiring small adjustments. Lead screws are typically only about half as efficient as ball screws, so they require double the torque to achieve the same thrust output of the screw. However, they offer cost efficient and compact solutions for high force applications. Moreover, they are resistant to back driving, removing the need of using a brake to hold the payload under a power loss.

The timing belt, the most simple and common drive train for linear motion systems, consists of two cogged pulleys; usually one driven and one idler, connected to a timing belt with an attached carrier. Timing belts are a robust mechanism for high-speed applications requiring long life and minimal maintenance where precision greater than 100 microns is sufficient. They can be operated at 100% duty cycle and are available in longer lengths than screw drives, making them ideal for long stroke applications requiring high dynamics.

Rack and pinion systems consist of a machined linear gear and a round mating toothed gear. Typically, the round gear is mobile and the rack is stationary. This type of drive train is useful for very long travels requiring high speed, but is not known for its precision. They offer high force density but they require maintenance to maintain the lubrication of the system. In addition, removing system backlash from this type of drive train is not always possible, and they can also often be quite noisy in operation.

Linear motors are made up of a row of magnets – simply put, a ‘flattened’ rotary motor – which interface with an electromagnetic carriage to move the payload in a linear direction. They offer high speed, acceleration and precision. The main drawback is the cost of implementing this technology due to the cost of the magnets and linear feedback devices required. Force density is also lower than for the other drive system. The lack of a mechanical connection between moving and static parts of a linear motor makes the use of it difficult in vertical applications.

The PETS principle

The list of potential performance characteristics that a designer might be interested in is long, so to focus the selection process more precisely, the options can be classified into the following categories: precision, expected life, throughput and special considerations (PETS).

When weighing the options with a focus on precision, always start with an understanding of your needs relative to resolution. The other considerations are repeatability, followed by accuracy and finally velocity control. Linear motors and precision ball screws are typically the most superior for precision characteristics. (The majority of motion applications do not require these high levels of precision, which is why the timing belt remains the most commonly applied technology.)

Upon examining the expected lifespans of all the options, mechanical efficiency will be the number one consideration, unless the requirement is for a dirty or otherwise harsh operating environment. High efficiency of the drive train is synonymous with long life and lower energy consumption. Issues such as wear resistance, dirt resistance and maintenance requirements are also important factors to be considered in this category. Because of their high efficiency and limited maintenance needs, timing belts are the go-to drive train of choice in this category.

The category of throughput can be considered by first examining the speed and acceleration or deceleration characteristics of each technology – depending on the length of linear travel required. If you have a longer travel where more of the cycle time is spent at the top velocity, speed is the most important. If the application requires shorter moves, acceleration and deceleration characteristics will take precedence. Depending on the application also other criteria, for example frequency response, duty cycle must be taken into account. Linear motors are unparalleled from a throughput perspective, due to their ability to achieve high speeds and accelerations, and given that they have no mechanical compliance, they have a high-frequency response.

Some special considerations to take into account when looking at each technology include material costs and implementation costs to ensure that the right combination of functionality is achieved at the minimum cost. Force density is also an increasingly important factor to bear in mind as machine designs continue to miniaturise, particularly when specifying end effectors or tooling mounted to an axis.

A precise balancing act

Some applications make the choice of a linear drive train relatively simple. For example, it’s clear to see from the above that timing belt drives are an ideal choice for long-travel applications requiring high linear velocity and acceleration. If the application travel length and required speed are moderate, but the acceleration should be high, or if a high positional accuracy is required, then a linear motor based drive would most likely be a better fit.

When the choice is not as obvious, all the available application parameters should be weighed carefully to make the best possible selection. If one key performance characteristic is optimised, it is likely that another performance indicator may be sacrificed. Analyse the requirements against the abilities of each technology using the PETS principle from the beginning, or contact the specialists at Parker Hannifin for specialist advice on modular linear drive solutions.

For more information contact Lisa de Beer, Parker Hannifin SA, +27 (0)11 961 0700, lisa.debeer@parker.com, www.parker.com/za


Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Cost-efficient production with 18 synchronous NC axes
June 2019, Beckhoff Automation , Motion Control & Drives
TwinCAT 3 controls highly efficient machine for processing of die-cast automotive parts.

Read more...
Rockwell Automation executes AC drive migration at Mozal ­Aluminium
June 2019, Rockwell Automation , Motion Control & Drives
For over 20 years, Rockwell Automation 1336 drives have delivered the drive control required across Mozal, an aluminium smelter near Maputo, Mozambique. Now the industrial automation leader is in the ...

Read more...
Drive solutions for energy efficient power transmission
June 2019 , Motion Control & Drives
Vert Energy is committed to providing energy-saving solutions for its diverse customer base. “Critical challenges facing industry include finding the most efficient ways to minimise energy consumption ...

Read more...
SEW-Eurodrive gives a foretaste of the future of automation
June 2019, SEW-Eurodrive , Motion Control & Drives
SEW-Eurodrive gave visitors to Africa Automation Fair 2019 a foretaste of its Movi-C modular automation system, ready-made for the requirements of Industry 4.0. This represents the next-generation of ...

Read more...
Servo motor equipped with SIL3 encoder
June 2019, Tectra Automation , Motion Control & Drives
The new MS2N synchronous servo motor is Tectra Automations’ latest product offering to the electric drives and controls industry. The range combines high dynamics, compact dimensions and excellent energy ...

Read more...
Case History 166: Feel and understanding, or lack thereof
May 2019, Michael Brown Control Engineering , Motion Control & Drives
I was present at a very interesting discussion the other day with people who are leaders in the automation and control industry. The subject was how jobs would disappear over the next decade or two as ...

Read more...
Parker Hannifin showcases its latest mobile solutions
May 2019, Parker Hannifin Sales Company South , News
Parker Hannifin presented its new, integrated electrified system solutions for sustainable mobile systems at bauma 2019. Visitors to Parker’s stand were able to see and experience a range of efficient ...

Read more...
Smart solution for incorporating machine-integrated robots
Africa Automation Fair 2019 Preview, SEW-Eurodrive , Motion Control & Drives
SEW-Eurodrive is showcasing the D5 delta robot, a smart solution for incorporating machine-integrated robots. The high-speed pick-and-place system includes tracking and Movikit robotics software. It ...

Read more...
Optimising energy requirements
Africa Automation Fair 2019 Preview, SEW-Eurodrive , Motion Control & Drives
A new development from SEW-Eurodrive is the Movigear mechatronic drive system, which combines an energy-efficient gear unit, motor and frequency inverter, and has received the TÜV SÜD Energy-Efficient ...

Read more...
Compact, cost-effective servo solution
Africa Automation Fair 2019 Preview, Elonics , Motion Control & Drives
elonics is introducing the latest addition from the LSIS servo family, the Xmotion L7C servo drives and motors. The L7C Series offers a cost-effective, high precision solution that is both compact in ...

Read more...