Fieldbus & Industrial Networking


Finding a better protocol conversion solution between PLCs and devices

April 2015 Fieldbus & Industrial Networking

Variable frequency drives (VFDs) are used in a number of industrial applications to save energy by controlling the speed of motors. VFDs are important since electric motor driven Systems (EMDSs) account for about 45% of all electricity consumption. In this white paper, we show how industrial Ethernet gateways can be used to create a communication gateway between VFDs and PLCs which is easy to install and maintain.

Overview

According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), EMDSs collectively use more electricity than any other single electrically powered application. Perhaps somewhat surprisingly, EMDS applications consume more than double the electricity of lighting, which comes in a distant second. It is estimated that globally, EMDS applications account for about 45% of all electricity consumption, with EMDS applications blamed for creating about 6040 megatons of carbon emissions per year. In addition, by some estimates, EMDS applications account for 70% of the electric energy used by industry, with common usages including pumps, fans, compressed air delivery, conveyors and motive power for other machinery.

The bottom line is that if you want to save energy and promote energy efficiency in your industrial applications, you need to reduce the amount of energy consumed by EMDS applications. This is where variable frequency drives (VFDs) come in. VFDs can control motor speed to save energy and can also decrease inrush current and apply a specified amount of torque.

VFDs can be integrated into a control system through a digital I/O, analog I/O, or communication interface connection. The communication interface is accessible via RS-232, RS-485 or Ethernet, and gives operators a convenient way to not only control the VFD, but also obtain information about it that might otherwise be unavailable. The main problem, however, is how to handle conflicting protocols. Most VFDs only support the Modbus RTU protocol, because it is easy and used widely for industrial automation applications. PLCs, however, are more likely to use an industrial Ethernet protocol, such as Modbus TCP or EtherNet/IP.

Communication requirements for VFD monitoring and control

A scada system usually includes an HMI and a PC, as well as PLCs and RTUs. The PC is normally used to issue supervisory level commands, with most of the control performed by the PLCs and RTUs. It is worth pointing out that even though PLCs and RTUs perform similar functions, there are key differences. PLCs, for example, have more sophisticated embedded control capabilities, making them more suitable for local control operations such as production lines. On the other hand, RTUs are suitable for connecting to devices distributed over a wider area since they have telemetry hardware capable of sending digital data to the supervisory system.

Since VFDs are often used to control motors that operate pumps, fans, or conveyor belts, which means they are part of a local control system, we would expect the VFDs to be connected to a PLC. For example, a typical architecture for controlling air quality in a factory building requires the scada operator to set a CO2 target level in ppm (parts per million). The resulting control system reads the current level from meters designed expressly for that purpose, and then the PLC issues the appropriate control signal to tell the VFDs how to adjust the speed of fans. In order to ensure that the optimisation control system operates as expected, provisions need to be made to guarantee that the VFDs use the correct industrial protocol to communicate with the PLC.

Existing solution

The first thing we should keep in mind is that PLCs available from different vendors do not necessarily support the same fieldbus protocol. For example, most Siemens PLCs support Profinet, Rockwell PLCs support EtherNet/IP, and Schneider PLCs support Modbus TCP. Individual vendors accommodate other fieldbus protocols by providing communication modules that are installed right next to the PLC. The advantages of using PLC communication modules are ease of installation and reliability. Since the modules are connected directly to the PLC, users do not need to install additional wiring. On the downside, the disadvantages of using PLC communication modules are the high cost and limited versatility.

On the VFD side of the connection, Modbus RTU is the protocol used by most vendors. When the need arises to accommodate other fieldbus protocols, most vendors provide PCBs (printed circuit boards) that plug directly into the VFD to provide the necessary protocol conversion. The advantages of using VFD communication modules are essentially the same as the advantages of using PLC modules. In addition, since the PCBs plug directly into a slot inside the VFD, they don’t take up any extra space. The cost is not particularly high, provided you only need one PCB module. But if you need to install two, three, or more units, you will need to spend two, three, or more times as much money to get your solution up and running. You should also factor in the amount of time required to install all of the modules.

Introduction to industrial Ethernet gateways

An attractive alternative to investing in PLC or VFD communication modules is the industrial Ethernet gateway. A gateway is a standalone device that converts a signal from one protocol to another. For example, a gateway could convert Modbus RTU to Modbus TCP, or convert Modbus RTU to Profibus. The gateway achieves this with a built-in CPU and memory storage capability. In effect, the VFDs and PLC communicate directly with the gateway instead of with each other. The process is transparent to the VFDs and PLC since the gateway handles all of the necessary protocol conversions.

The benefits of using industrial Ethernet gateways

If you decide to use an industrial Ethernet gateway solution, you will need to spend time learning how to use the system, and also expend a certain amount of effort configuring and managing gateways as they are added to your system. However, compared to using PLC or VFD communication modules, the gateway provides several attractive benefits. In fact, if you use a gateway that comes with a user-friendly interface and good management functions, the additional effort required to configure and manage the gateway will be minimal.

A good way of distinguishing the gateway solution from the PLC/VFD module solution is to compare the two solutions from a hardware and software perspective.

Easy and cost-effective hardware integration

If you decide to use a VFD communication module, you will need to remove the VFD’s housing to install it. As you might imagine, this operation could take quite a bit of time, particularly if you have dozens of VFDs that need to be upgraded, in which case the VFD module solution could be quite costly. In fact, you might even have trouble finding a system integrator who will agree to upgrade an existing system in this way. As far as PLC modules are concerned, installation is easier, but you will need to sacrifice one PLC slot that otherwise could be used for a different purpose. If your PLCs are in a different location than the devices, you will need to contend with the fact that PLCs only support a serial connection. Using a gateway to connect your devices to a common Ethernet base is the preferred solution because of the flexibility it adds to your system. Another factor to consider is that with an Ethernet-based environment, you can use fibre to avoid interference from electro­magnetic noise.

Versatile and simple software integration

The most important benefit of using a gateway solution is versatility. For example, you may want to monitor different aspects of your VFDs after your system is up and running. Or, you may want to install additional VFDs in your system after it has already been in operation for one or more years. In fact, this is a very common situation faced by engineers responsible for managing a factory. With a gateway solution, you can reserve I/O space in the PLC and the gateway configuration for future expansion. When it comes time to add new VFDs, you will only need to configure the gateway, instead of tweaking the PLC software. If you use a PLC module solution, you will need to update the PLC software by adding commands for dealing with the module. Another advantage of using a gateway is that it has built-in CPU and memory that enables the gateway to handle protocol conversion by itself, instead of using the PLC for this purpose. With a gateway solution, your system will be simpler and easier to maintain.

Moxa industrial Ethernet gateways

Moxa’s MGate family offers a variety of gateway solutions that can be used for VFD applications. MGate gateways have a rugged design suitable for harsh, high temperature environments, and provide the reliability for dealing with electronic noise. Since MGate gateways are PI and ODVA certified and support all major PLC protocols, including Modbus TCP, EtherNet/IP, Profibus, and Profinet, you won’t have any trouble connecting your VFDs to any of the commonly used PLCs. In addition, Moxa’s MGate gateways come with a user-friendly web interface, a microSD card slot for configuration backup, and alarm and system log management functions to reduce your maintenance effort.



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

EtherCAT interoperability removes industrial networking barriers
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Selecting the right communication technology is one of the most important decisions engineers make, and interoperability helps with that decision. Key development tools and standards ensure interoperability among many EtherCAT devices and manufacturers.

Read more...
Boosting long-distance critical signal delivery in mining
Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
In mining applications globally, conveyor belts of up to 20 km are used to transport ore. Damage to conveyors often causes cargo spillage and creates major safety risks. Ian Loudon, international sales manager at remote monitoring specialist, Omniflex explains how these challenges can be combatted using bidirectional fibre optic modules.

Read more...
Industrial PCs with new processor generations and increased performance
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
PC-based control technology from Beckhoff has always benefited from the convergence of automation and the IT world. Current examples include the use of the latest industry-standard processor generations, high-quality and demand-optimised flash memory, and the long-term availability version of Windows 11.

Read more...
New EtherCAT digital input and output terminals
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The new EL14xx and EL24xx EtherCAT Terminals from Beckhoff complement the company’s existing broad portfolio in the area of digital input/output, and combine proven functions with an optimised circuit architecture.

Read more...
Monitoring system and motor status in real time with minimal
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Beckhoff’s AM8000, AM8300, AM8500, AM8700 and AM8800 series servomotors are available with the innovative Beckhoff Smart System Diagnosis. With B/SSD, it is possible to monitor motors and systems in real time with minimal effort and to implement effective predictive maintenance.

Read more...
Safety controller for industrial PCs
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
With TwinSAFE, Beckhoff offers an extensive portfolio of software and hardware components for functional safety. This range is continuously being expanded and developed, as demonstrated by numerous new safety I/Os and the TwinCAT Safety PLC with EL6910 functionality.

Read more...
Analogue input module
Vepac Electronics Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The D6400 analogue input module from Vepac contains seven differential inputs for measuring DC voltages, current signals such as 4-20 mA and thermocouple temperature sensors.

Read more...
Planar motor system for quality assurance
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Achieving the shortest possible inspection times, even when working with different components, is paramount when it comes to series production. This is precisely what special machine builder, stoba Sondermaschinen set out to achieve with its InspectorONE optical inspection system, which is based on deep learning and features the Beckhoff XPlanar planar motor system at the conveyor system core.

Read more...
Futureproof your industrial network security with OT-centric cyber security
RJ Connect Editor's Choice
To achieve digital transformation, industrial operators must first address the daunting task of merging their information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT) infrastructure. In this article, we focus on the importance of strong OT network security and provide some tips on how to strengthen cybersecurity for industrial operations.

Read more...
Industrial gateway for Ethernet network
Vepac Electronics Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
IEG-3000 is an industrial gateway that connects different generation devices to an Ethernet network.

Read more...