Editor's Choice


Open Process Automation moves to the proof of concept stage

June 2018 Editor's Choice

Open Process Automation was once again a hot topic at the 2018 ARC Industry Forum in Orlando, Florida, earlier this year. Among the highlights was the session focusing on the current status of several open process automation initiatives currently in progress. The session featured the first public presentation on the ExxonMobil proof of concept demonstration project.

In the same Forum session, Abdullah Al-Khalifah presented Saudi Aramco’s experimental Data-centric Open Process Automation, and BASF’s Michael Krauss (supported by ExxonMobil’s Don Bartusiak) presented the NAMUR Open Architecture (NOA) vision. Krauss and Bartusiak both made a point of discussing the synergies and a cooperative path forward. In his presentation, Al-Khalifah also mentioned that Saudi Aramco is committed to support and work with the Open Process Automation Forum (a forum of The Open Group) to capture experience and knowledge to support the OPAF standardisation efforts to achieve the defined objectives.

Significantly, this was the first time that parties from these three parallel initiatives presented publicly together in a joint session.

Open Process Automation: moving beyond the art of possibilities

David DeBari, prototype lead engineer for the OPAF program at Exx-onMobil, worked closely with a team at LockheedMartin and others to develop a prototype proof of concept system based on the OPAF architecture envisioned by ExxonMobil and the industry standards identified by the Open Process Automation Forum. In his first of a kind ARC Industry Forum presentation on the system, DeBari proudly reported: “We’ve been able to transform from the art of possibilities into a running, proof of concept system.”

As DeBari explained, the objective for the proof of concept project was to demonstrate the feasibility of the architecture to deliver the targeted multivendor interoperability through standards (without resorting to gateways or translators), interchangeability to enable components to be individually and freely replaced between vendors (without having to modify the underlying logic), configuration and application portability, and application development flexibility.

DeBari then presented a series of slides that showed how all these objectives were met in a concept system controlling a simulated natural draft fired heater. The team chose this process due to its widespread use in process industries, the many PID control loops involved, plus the need for constraint controls.

Running proof of concept system. (Source: ExxonMobil).
Running proof of concept system. (Source: ExxonMobil).

Proof of concept passes stress tests

As part of the stress testing, the team broke the control application into multiple parts and distributed these over a dozen different DCNs. According to DeBari, the control still worked flawlessly.

Due to concerns previously expressed about potential latency issues in the real-time bus, the team tested the control loops at 100 microseconds. While this appears to be well below the ultimate bus capacity, it is still far faster than required for most continuous process control applications.

Moving forward?

So, what is the next step? According to DeBari, now that the proof of concept has demonstrated the desired characteristics on a simulated process, the next step is to move to an on-process pilot project later this year. ExxonMobil has already identified an internal site for this pilot and encourages other operating companies to not only join and actively participate in the Open Process Automation Forum activities, but to initiate additional OPAF development efforts, pilots, and field trials, ideally across a variety of different industries. The goal is to initiate field trials of pioneer applications in 2020 and achieve full technical readiness in 2021.

What makes these complementary open automation initiatives so exciting and important, is that they have been initiated and driven by end user organisations and are receiving increasing support from the suppliers, which is critical for ultimate success. Based on what ARC learned at this Forum session, we are also reasonably optimistic that these initiatives will converge, which is also critical for ultimate market success.

Following the success of the OPAF proof of concept project, ARC encourages end user organisations across the process industries to learn more about the initiative and, if deemed appropriate for their applications, both join the Open Process Automation Forum as a member and, if possible, participate in the upcoming on-process field trials. This would provide both an opportunity to get a head start toward achieving a long-term resolution to the chronic system obsolescence issues faced by many process manufacturers and influence the direction of this technology as it develops.

And while the open process automation concept challenges the current business models of many process automation and technology suppliers, it also offers numerous new opportunities.

For more information contact Paul Miller, ARC Advisory Group, +1 781 471 1141, [email protected], www.arcweb.com





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Simple and efficient level measurement in the mining, minerals and metals industries
Endress+Hauser South Africa Editor's Choice Level Measurement & Control
Measuring devices in the mining, minerals and metals industries face the challenge of varying material states and long distances in measurement height. Endress+Hauser’s answer to these challenges is the new Micropilot family.

Read more...
PC-based control for fertiliser
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
On a farm in the USA, valuable ammonia is extracted from slurry and processed into ammonium sulphate. NSI Byosis has transformed this complex process into a flexible modular system. This modular approach requires an automation solution with flexible scalability in both hardware and software, which this Dutch company has found in PC-based control from Beckhoff.

Read more...
Loop signature 28: Things to consider when tuning.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
I was giving a course at a remote mine in the middle of the Namibian desert. We were discussing tuning responses, and as I always do on my courses, I mentioned that in my opinion ¼ amplitude damped tuning is not desirable, and is in fact not good.

Read more...
Control without complexity
Editor's Choice Motion Control & Drives
In an era where precision, performance and smart control define industrial success, the right driver can make all the difference. At Axiom Hydraulics, we’ve seen firsthand how the Sun Hydraulics XMD series transforms hydraulic systems, from mining and construction to agriculture and automation.

Read more...
The thermal combustion balancing act
Editor's Choice
From carbon taxes to export tariffs, and cost containment to security of supply and sustainability, companies are under increasing pressure to switch to greener fuel sources. Associated Energy Services warns that this pivotal change has some potentially serious knock-on effects.

Read more...
What’s driving the IE3 motor revolution?
WEG Africa Editor's Choice
The International Efficiency 3 (IE3) motor standard will soon become South Africa’s legal minimum standard, mandating that local suppliers offer more efficient electric motors. What is driving this change, and how does it affect the many industries that rely on these modern electric workhorses?

Read more...
Unlocking the smart factory
ElectroMechanica Editor's Choice Motion Control & Drives
At ElectroMechanica, we recognise that transitioning to smart automation isn’t just about adopting new technology; it’s about solving real challenges. Labour shortages, rising costs and downtime due to outdated machinery make digital transformation essential for long-term competitiveness.

Read more...
Case History 197: Bad reboiler temperature control.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Flow Measurement & Control
It is very important that reboiler temperature controls operate well in petrochemical refineries, or the product quality can really suffer. I was asked to check such a control in a refinery where they were having problems with one of these controls.

Read more...
The future of industrial automation: fieldbus and industrial networking
LAPP Southern Africa Editor's Choice
As a global leader in integrated solutions in the field of cable and connection technology, LAPP recognises that fieldbus and industrial networking technologies are pivotal in shaping the future of manufacturing and production processes.

Read more...
AI-driven innovations with CCTV and cyber security
RJ Connect Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The fast progress of artificial intelligence (AI) and video analytics is redefining the rail surveillance landscape. Advancements have bolstered proactive event detection, predictive maintenance and enhanced situational awareness.

Read more...