Editor's Choice


Integrating HACCP management in manufacturing execution systems

October 2024 Editor's Choice

Why HACCP is important in the food industry

Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) is a systematic approach designed to identify, evaluate and control hazards throughout the food production process, providing a robust framework for safeguarding public health across various food industries, including meat, seafood, vegetables, and fruit processing. HACCP principles are applicable across all sectors of the food industry, from production and processing to distribution and service. These principles have gained universal acceptance among government agencies and trade associations, highlighting their importance in safeguarding public health. By systematically applying HACCP principles, food producers can enhance safety and quality in their operations, ultimately benefitting both consumers and the industry as a whole.

Maintaining readily available, accurate and up-to-date records is crucial to prove the execution of monitoring HACCP activities and to demonstrate compliance with regulatory requirements. Documentation serves as evidence of the effectiveness of the HACCP plan and supports communication between all the operational teams, including production, food safety and quality. Essential records include hazard analyses, critical control point (CCP) monitoring logs, and documentation of corrective actions taken.

Why MES is important in the food Industry

In tandem, manufacturing execution systems (MES) monitor and manage manufacturing processes, facilitating real-time data collection, and enhance operational efficiency. At its core, an MES is designed to track and document the transformation of raw materials into finished products through the different processes and equipment involved in this transformation. It accomplishes this by collecting data directly from equipment and operators on the shop floor, offering a transparent view of the manufacturing process by making the information available in real-time through dashboards and human machine interfaces (HMI).

An MES, depending on the specific company and its processes, can include functionalities such as scheduling, order execution, production reporting, labour management, quality management and maintenance management. Through these capabilities, an MES provides critical information that supports informed decision making at all organisational levels.

One of the significant roles of the MES in a company is its ability to integrate data from various manufacturing systems such as scada, HMI and quality management systems (LIMS and QMS), and make it available within context to the company enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. By functioning as a central hub for data integration, an MES provides a comprehensive view of the production process, enabling manufacturers to identify inefficiencies and streamline operations. This real-time data monitoring allows for preventive maintenance and quick responses to production issues, ultimately enhancing operational efficiency and reducing downtime. In addition, the data collected, transformed and made available at this level also provides critical information needed by the ERP system for profitability calculations and by executives for decision making.

Why is integration important for food producers

Integration between these two critical systems aims to streamline compliance with food safety regulations while optimising production efficiency and reducing costs, making it particularly valuable in today’s competitive food market. If we think back a few years, a whole brand of food products disappeared from South African retail shelves almost overnight, due to a lack of readily available food safety data and a failure in HACCP practices.

One of the primary benefits of integrating HACCP management into an MES is the improvement in operational efficiency and the increase in data accuracy. By automating data collection and real-time monitoring, manufacturers can reduce manual data entry errors and improve data reliability. This streamlining leads to faster response times and shorter production cycles, ultimately lowering costs and increasing productivity. It can also enable earlier identification of potential issues and allow for preventive measures to be taken, as opposed to reactive corrective action only after major issues become apparent.

By leveraging MES software, manufacturers can effectively monitor CCPs, automate data collection, and improve traceability throughout the production process, thus ensuring adherence to stringent food safety standards. In addition, integration fosters better collaboration among stakeholders and facilitates continuous improvement in food safety protocols, which is essential for maintaining compliance in an increasingly regulated environment. Integration results in a more interconnected understanding of food safety risks, enabling producers to adopt a proactive approach to compliance. A unified system simplifies the process by consolidating various standards into a single framework, allowing businesses to focus on comprehensive compliance rather than navigating multiple individual standards at different points in the process. Furthermore, properly defined and integrated traceability systems can improve transparency throughout the supply chain, enabling rapid identification and containment of safety issues.

What is the challenge for food producers?

Despite its benefits, the integration of HACCP with the MES presents certain challenges. The complexity of integrating disparate systems can lead to difficulties in setup and configuration, which in turn leads to the need for complex technical training to ensure successful implementation. Additionally, issues such as data silos and inconsistencies in data formats complicate the integration of HACCP within the MES, further impeding successful implementation. In addition, a lack of standardised processes within companies may hinder implementation and scalability, potentially resulting in additional manual data entry, increased deviations and longer release times. To mitigate these challenges, it is recommended that companies engage cross-functional teams to assess and prioritise their integration needs, thereby ensuring a comprehensive decision-making process.

After the technical challenges have been addressed, companies also have to overcome the people issues such as resistance to change and mistrust of technology. Many South African enterprises face systemic issues related to workforce development, underscoring the need for comprehensive training programmes tailored to the specific needs of their employees. Enhancing access to training and education programmes for food handlers and processors is vital for promoting a culture of food safety and compliance. Improved awareness and knowledge enable stakeholders to implement better food safety management systems and reduce contamination risks, ultimately enhancing food safety outcomes.

Collaborative efforts among regulatory agencies, industry associations and educational institutions can promote the development of effective training initiatives, but this is unfortunately not happening in a practical sense.

What is next for food producers?

As the food industry evolves, the fusion of MES and HACCP principles will continue reshaping operational practices, driven by technological advancements such as artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML) and the internet of things (IoT), and also an increasing focus on sustainability and quality control measures. The adoption of cutting-edge technologies such as AI, ML and IoT is poised to redefine how MES and HACCP systems operate and interact. These technologies will enable real-time monitoring and data analysis, allowing food producers to respond rapidly to safety hazards and operational inefficiencies. In addition, AI and ML solutions will combine historical real-time and transactional data into models that can predict process, quality and hygiene outcomes, thus highlighting and preventing adverse conditions for food safety occurring in the process.


About Gerhard Greef


Gerhard Greef.

Gerhard Greeff has qualifications in chemical engineering, production management and quality management. He has been involved in manufacturing since 1987 and with software development and integration in the manufacturing operations management (MOM) field since 1999. Gerhard believes that a properly designed and implemented MOM system will improve operational effectiveness and efficiency and can add tremendous business value for any manufacturing company.

For more information contact Gerhard Greeff, Implementation Manager, TransLution Software, +27 11 803 5854, rsa.support@translutionsoftware.com, www.translutionsoftware.com


Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Connecting every transport node
RJ Connect Editor's Choice Data Acquisition & Telemetry
Stockholm's bus system strategically links urban mainline, suburban mainline, non-mainline routes, community service buses and night buses. To acquire and process data from multiple sources and analyse onboard information on their moving buses, Transdev sought a dependable and powerful onboard computer. It teamed up with CatAB, Moxa’s local representative, known for delivering top-notch industrial data communication boards and equipment since 1988.

Read more...
Local range of planetary units
SEW-EURODRIVE Editor's Choice Motion Control & Drives
As SEW-EURODRIVE South Africa actively extends its offerings to customers, the SEW PPK and SEW P2.e industrial gearbox ranges are good examples of solutions that are well suited to the local business environment.

Read more...
Case History 195: Unstable reboiler steam flow
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice
A high-pressure steam flow control in a reboiler on a column in a petrochemical refinery continually cycled when placed in automatic. Several attempts had been made to tune the controller, but these had been unsuccessful.

Read more...
Open control system for retrofit of conveyor control system
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice
For every online retailer, warehouse logistics is part of the critical infrastructure. An Australian office equipment supplier has retrofitted the warehouse logistics installation of its central warehouse, and replaced the proprietary decentralised controllers of the conveyor lines with PC-based control from Beckhoff, based on powerful EtherCAT communication.

Read more...
Digital industrial platforms and why they are important
Editor's Choice
One of the most significant trends driving digital transformation is the emergence of digital industrial platforms. This article will briefly explore what digital industrial platforms are, why they are important, and how they might shape the future of industrial automation.

Read more...
Celebrating 65 years: rebuilding and redefining its legacy
Editor's Choice News
Founded in 1959 by Neill Simpson, Axiom Hydraulics has grown into one of South Africa’s elite hydraulic companies. Over the past six and a half decades they’ve weathered many challenges, but none as devastating as the fire of 2023.

Read more...
Young robotics team takes world title
igus Editor's Choice News
In an inspiring demonstration of innovation and teamwork, Texpand, a young South African robotics team, recently made history by winning the 2024 FIRST Tech Challenge World Championships.

Read more...
SAIMC: It’s not black and white
SAIMC Editor's Choice SAIMC
Grey imports are a problem worldwide, not least in the automation industry in South Africa. The Supplier Advisory Council (SAC) operates under the umbrella of SAIMC, and is tackling this problem head-on.

Read more...
Loop signature 25: Tuning part 3 - Results of tuning a particular simple self-regulating process by several different methods.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice
A couple of SWAG methods of tuning were given in the previous Loop Signature article. I have tuned a simple self-regulating process using those methods, and two other tuning methods, one of them being the sophisticated Protuner tuning package, which is the system I employ. The tests were performed on a very accurate and powerful simulation package, and the results are compared below.

Read more...
PC-based control for advanced hydrogen storage technology
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice PLCs, DCSs & Controllers
The proportion of renewable energies from solar, wind and water is rising continuously. However, sufficient storage options are of the essence to use these energies as efficiently as possible. GKN Hydrogen offers a particularly compact and safe option, low-pressure metal hydride hydrogen storage systems with PC-based control from Beckhoff.

Read more...