News


Scada review 2011

May 2011 News

SA Instrumentation and Control contributing editor, Andrew Ashton, has started working on the annual Scada Review feature that will be published in next month’s issue. The questionnaire has been sent to all the scada vendors out there and we are once again looking forward to publishing the feature that gives South African control professionals the opportunity to read objective opinions from vendors and system integrators, as well as the end users. We will be sticking to the format of last year, which proved popular with its extra detail about the SI’s and project application statistics.

In the introduction to last year’s review we commented that changes in the global economic climate were probably the reason that the reviews were no longer dominated by projects in the mining and minerals processing industries. In fact, we had a nice mix of responses about projects in the automotive, cement, electric cable and oil and gas sectors.

We also voiced our opinion about the importance of evaluating the total cost of ownership of a solution. To recap, we believe that the initial purchase price, while obviously important, should not be the only determining factor in the procurement process. As a minimum, the initial cost, configuration costs and maintenance costs of IT infrastructure and scada need to be evaluated over the expected life of the system. It will be interesting to see if there has been a shift in end user perspective on the matter.

Since last year’s review, arguably the biggest news stories about scada have related to issues of security. As the shop and the top floor networks converge into a single enterprise wide entity, the process control layer has become more exposed to the threat of ‘infection’. Couple this with the exponential increase in the sophistication of hacker tools and the issue of enterprise wide network security down to the PLC level suddenly becomes a major concern. SA Instrumentation and Control will be reporting on the subject in a separate series of articles, but expect it to have a higher level of prominence in the questionnaire when Scada Review 2012 comes around.

Michael Brown goes online

We have some exciting news from our other contributing editor as well. In line with the trend towards content online, Mike Brown has agreed that as from now his popular series of Control Loop articles may be hosted on the SAI&C website. They will reside in the existing e-category ‘Control Systems Design’.

After 20 years spent honing his skills in the field as well as in the classroom, Mike is a fountain of knowledge on the subject with an unbridled enthusiasm for teaching. Outspoken in his frustration at the lack of understanding for the subject in industry, he believes that while the control equipment is becoming more sophisticated the base layers are not working any better and that, in many cases, the operators are running the plants not the control systems.

Mike, your articles have already made a contribution by spreading the word in print. Now that they are going online and will be accessible to anyone with an Internet connection, let us hope that the benefit of your experience will have an even bigger impact in a changing economy that is going to demand ever higher levels of efficiency.

Steven Meyer

Editor: SA Instrumentation & Control

steven@technews.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

John Thompson secures order for bagasse-fired boiler
News
John Thompson, a division of ACTOM, has secured an order for a 320 t/h bagasse-fired boiler for what is set to become the world’s largest greenfield sugar mill development in Indonesia.

Read more...
From the editor's desk: Consistently not stupid
Technews Publishing (SA Instrumentation & Control) News
Over the years I’ve followed Charlie Munger. He’s considered to be one of the greatest investors and thinkers on decision making in the past century, and spent six decades as Warren Buffett’s business ...

Read more...
South Africa’s space balls
Editor's Choice News
South African engineers are preparing to take low-frequency radio astronomy to the Moon with three locally developed B.A.L.L.S. spheres aboard China’s Chang’e-8 mission. This could pave the way for a 55-antenna lunar array and marks another step in the country’s growing space engineering capability.

Read more...
RS South Africa announces 2026 Student Project Fund winners
RS South Africa News
RS South Africa has awarded 13 engineering students with R10?000 worth of products each through its 2026 Student Project Fund, supporting projects spanning renewable energy, robotics, warehouse automation and STEM education.

Read more...
Certified gas meter module
News
Sensirion’s next-generation SGM5304 gas meter module has completed certification to the harmonised EN 17526 standard, simplifying MID approval and speeding customers’ route to market.

Read more...
Trafo Power Solutions expands market share
News
Trafo Power Solutions is expanding its market share in mining, industrial, infrastructure, data centre and renewable energy applications through technical expertise, application-specific engineering and responsive customer support.

Read more...
Engineering solutions to keep coal power plants viable in a renewables-driven grid
News
Steinmüller Africa showcased engineering solutions at Enlit Africa 2026 that let existing coal-fired power stations run efficiently at much lower loads, helping the grid absorb a growing share of variable renewable energy.

Read more...
Trafo Power Solutions returns to Electra Mining Africa
News
Trafo Power Solutions returns to Electra Mining Africa 2026 with a portfolio that has expanded well beyond dry-type transformers into fully engineered electrical power solutions for mining, industrial and infrastructure operations across Africa.

Read more...
SAIMC INSPIRE conference extends abstract submission deadline
SAIMC SAIMC News
Following requests from our sponsors, the SAIMC INSPIRE conference has officially extended the abstract submission deadline to 28 August 2026.

Read more...
Pomini Tenova and Siemens advance roll grinder technology
Siemens South Africa News
Pomini Tenova and Siemens strengthen their long-standing partnership to support the revamping and modernisation of roll grinders with advanced CNC and automation technology.

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved