Motion Control & Drives


Electric and pneumatic drives: friends or foes?

August 2007 Motion Control & Drives

Is pneumatic technology able to meet the demands of modern automation technology, or is it inferior to electrical solutions? Industrial automation calls not only for speed and precision but also flexibility. Thanks to initiatives like the Festo modular mechatronic handling system there is a clear trend towards hybrid systems. The win-win solution to this question is hybrid drives that combine the advantages of both types of drive.

Electric drives are precise and flexible. They are ideal when forces need to be developed quickly and positions need to be approached precisely. Electric drives offer high accuracies, constant speeds, good controllability, defined travel profiles and rigidity under load conditions. However, they do need cooling systems for use with heavy loads and duty cycles.

Large loads are generally not a problem for pneumatic drives, which are inexpensive, unaffected by difficult environmental factors such as dust, oil, water or cleaning agents, long-lasting and easy to install and operate. Used with appropriate sensors and valve technology, pneumatic drives are also freely positionable, but, at best, achieve a precision of 0,1 mm.

Users need to find the right drive technology for each application and the selected components must perform reliably. If all the components of a hybrid system are obtained from a single source and are mechanically compatible, there is no more the question of 'electrics versus pneumatics?' The answer is 'electrics and pneumatics'.

Electrical drives

Festo's system solutions specialists act as partners within this selection process for the design and commissioning of complete handling systems. They combine components from the company's comprehensive product range to meet customers' individual requirements. This helps machine builders save considerable time and money in their planning and design work.

The handling axis HME is one example from Festo's comprehensive modular system. The more delicate the application, the better: This axis offers a repetition accuracy of ±0,015 mm and is thus appropriate for applications such as the precision fitting of sensitive components. German special machine builder, Manfred Merklinger Werkzeug- and Maschinenbau, has integrated this axis into a machine in which tiny springs are fitted to a miniature motor. The HME handling axis combines backlash-free heavy-duty ball-bearing guide, high-precision linear motor drive, displacement encoder and reference sensor, all integrated to save space.

The pre-assembled HME electrical handling axis and SFC-LAC positioning controller
The pre-assembled HME electrical handling axis and SFC-LAC positioning controller

Pneumatic drives

With appropriate sensors, software and valve technology, pneumatics can deliver the free positionability of closed-loop drive technology. Servo pneumatics, as an alternative to the familiar types of pneumatic and electric drives, permits movement of a pneumatic cylinder with closed-loop speed and position control. Servo pneumatic drives are every bit as good as electric drives when it comes to dynamic positioning. The system consists of a pneumatic cylinder with an integrated displacement encoder, a proportional valve in place of a simple switching valve, and a position controller such as the Festo SPC200.

A milking machine built by the Dutch machine builder Lely Industries NV is equipped with a servo pneumatic system. The idea behind this milking robot is that the cows themselves decide whether to be milked or not. If they do wish to be milked, they enter a box in which the milking robot is able by means of a transponder to detect the cow's specific data such as weight and size. It can also detect whether the cow has already been milked a short time before. The robot arm, a kinematic mechanism with three pneumatic cylinders, operates flexibly thanks to servo pneumatics, thus ensuring that the cow is not injured. A laser sensor monitors the movement of the cow so that the robot arm can locate the cow's udder.

Thanks to servo pneumatics, the milking robot is flexible
Thanks to servo pneumatics, the milking robot is flexible

Hybrid solutions

The Festo modular handling system allows users to exploit the individual strengths of matched electric and (servo-) pneumatic drives. The trend is moving towards combination drives in which pneumatics and electrics work hand in hand. The drive of the future is a hybrid drive in which a pneumatic drive and electric drive are integrated into a cylinder and work in parallel on the same handling task. This hybrid drive combines the advantages of pneumatics - robustness, durability, low costs and easy installation and operation - with the accuracy and dynamism of electric drives. Together, the two technologies create a high-performance drive that can operate quickly and with high precision in confined spaces while transporting large loads.

For more information contact Joanne Dix, Festo, +27 (0)11 971 5560, [email protected], www.festo.com



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Medium voltage drive for enhanced energy efficiency and process optimisation
Schneider Electric South Africa Motion Control & Drives
Schneider Electric South Africa has unveiled its cutting-edge Altivar Process ATV6100 medium voltage (MV) drive range, designed to enhance energy efficiency and operational reliability across various industries.

Read more...
Powerful high-precision hexapod
Motion Control & Drives
With the HEX150-125HL, Aerotech is launching the latest generation of its hexapod technology. The compact six-axis positioner combines precise movements with high load capacity and simple integration.

Read more...
Servicing the electric motor sector
Motion Control & Drives
Hexagon Electrical has expanded its manufacturing and service capabilities to meet the growing demand for customised, high-performance specialised electric motors in heavy engineering, and hazardous industrial and mining applications.

Read more...
Control system for deep antenna
Rockwell Automation Motion Control & Drives
When a major university in South Korea set out to build a 21-metre deep space antenna, the researchers needed a control system that could track celestial objects with pinpoint accuracy, a level of precision they thought was out of reach. By partnering with Rockwell Automation, they discovered that the right technology and support could turn their vision into reality.

Read more...
Manufacturers should go PFAS-Free
igus Motion Control & Drives
igus continues to develop engineered plastics that are free of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS-free) in response to mounting evidence of severe environmental and health hazards caused by the chemicals.

Read more...
South African paper producer partners with ABB
Motion Control & Drives
Neopak, a leading manufacturer of containerboard and paper products, has renewed its partnership with global technology company, ABB to upgrade the existing automation system at its Rosslyn Paper Mill in Pretoria.

Read more...
ABB supplies electromagnetic stirrer to world’s largest electric arc furnace
Motion Control & Drives
ABB has secured an order from Çolakoglu Metalurji. for an ArcSave electromagnetic stirrer to be installed on one of the world’s largest electric arc furnaces (EAF)

Read more...
Compact, powerful and green mini-picker
Motion Control & Drives
SkyJacks has introduced Jekko’s Mini Picker to the southern African market. This is a compact, highly versatile and environmentally friendly electric mini-picker that is set to redefine lifting capabilities across multiple industries.

Read more...
Redefining industrial lifting
Motion Control & Drives
The Konecranes S-series hoist redefines industrial lifting through its integration of a ground-breaking synthetic rope with smart features, a lifting capacity of 20 tons, and the ability to adapt to diverse girder configurations.

Read more...
Bühler drives innovation in agriculture and food processing
Motion Control & Drives
NAMPO 2025 is set to be one of the most significant agricultural events in southern Africa. It provides a unique platform for Bühler to showcase its advanced solutions that are designed to improve efficiency, sustainability and profitability in the agricultural sector.

Read more...