Mass Measurement


Positive displacement vs Coriolis meters

March 2020 Mass Measurement

Coriolis meters are the meters of choice in many liquid measurement applications. But, what about custody transfer applications in the oil industry where every drop counts?

Positive displacement (PD) is a practical and accurate method to achieve volumetric measurement of refined hydrocarbons, according to tests undertaken by Brodie International in the USA. Brodie is a world-class manufacturer of positive displacement technology metering solutions for liquid transfer applications in the energy industry.

The tests revealed that Brodie’s BiRotor Plus (BR+) meter can offer advantages over Coriolis meters for the highest accuracy and reliability. Here are the reasons:

• Moving parts: the measurement tubes of a Coriolis meter continuously vibrate at a high frequency, which can result in material fatigue and reduced life expectancy. The BR+ has two solid moving parts (the rotors) with no material contact, except for its hybrid ceramic bearings and timing gears, resulting in a field-proven life expectancy.

• Pulse generation: the relationship between the vibration of the tubes inside the Coriolis meter and its pulse output is complex with pulses calculated and generated by a microprocessor. This requires complex electronic filtering of the vibration signal and can cause a delay between flow and pulse output. The BR+ generates real pulses that originate directly from the rotor motion.

The pulse output is uniform and works well with all proving methods including Small Volume Provers using pulse interpolation.

• Pressure drop and changes of pressure: Coriolis meters experience a high pressure drop due to the splitting of the flow into two smaller vibrating tubes. Although it handles the same flow rates, the BR+ is less sensitive to pressure changes.

Meter performance

• Linearity and repeatability: with a published linearity of ±0.075% and a repeatability of 0.02%, the BR+ is a highly accurate custody transfer meter. As with other PD meters, the accuracy of the BR+ improves with increasing viscosity.

Internal product residue

Residue can cause instability in Coriolis tubes, which has implications on the accuracy.

Crude oils which contain paraffin wax often coat the inside tubes of the Coriolis meter. Likewise, viscous oil creates an internal layer on the tubes, the ‘boundary layer’. There are correction procedures in the software to correct this, but these need to be monitored and turned on or off. This adds another level of complication because the operator needs to know when it is needed and when it is not. The BR+ meter is self-cleaning by design and does not require compensation for residue.


Maintenance and proving

• Coriolis meters need to be taken out and sent to the manufacturer for repair. The tubes can suffer from fatigue caused by its high frequency vibration and their replacement is costly. With periodic maintenance, BR+ meters can last for decades and be repaired on site.

• The zero-offset (during low or no flow) of a Coriolis meter needs to be checked and verified periodically. Errors can occur if the tubes become mechanically unbalanced due to coating or erosion. The BR+ does not require Zero setting.

• Complex electronic filtering by a Coriolis meter can cause delays in flow/response measurement. Therefore, a minor change in flow during a proof run can translate to poor repeatability in a Coriolis meter. The pulses of Brodie’s BiRotor+ are created in real-time directly from its pulse wheel, without electronic manipulation. This makes proving straightforward and easy.

Testing and results

The testing conducted by Brodie consisted of 10 repeatability checks at flowrates from 70 to 900 GPM in 100 gallon increments.

The linearity curve of the 4” BR+ meter was nearly flat. The linearity curve of the 3” Coriolis meter was a steady increase. On the meters tested, the linearity of the BR+ meter was ±0.033% vs ±0.106% for the Coriolis meter.

The 3” Coriolis repeatability spread constantly increased at flowrates greater than 500 GPM. At 900 GPM, the repeatability spread was over four times greater than at 500 GPM.

Based on the results achieved, Brodie calculated the implication on cost due to the uncertainties of both meters.

Assumptions

Application: truck loading rack.

Operating flow rate: 600 gpm (2270 lpm).

Operation: 10 hours/day; 365 days/year.

Annual volume: 131 4000 000 gallons/year.

Gasoline cost per gallon: $0.70.

Uncertainty cost per year:

Coriolis: 1,00042 [max meter factor] – 1,00017 [min meter factor] = 0,00025 [uncertainty].

131 400 000 gallons x 0,00025 [uncertainty] = 32 850 gallons/year.

BiRotor+: 1,00030 [max meter factor] – 1,00016 [min meter factor] = 0,00014 [uncertainty].

131 400 000 gallons x 0.00014 [uncertainty] = 18 396 gallons/year.

Difference between both meters = 14 454 gallons/year i.e. a saving of $10 118/year using the BiRotor+

For more information contact Phil Dawson, Soliflo, +27 11 792 2196, phil@soliflo.co.za, www.soliflo.co.za


Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Belt conveyor weighing applications
June 2020, Loadtech Loadcells , Mass Measurement
Loadtech’s LT1320 is a precision digital indicator for belt weighing applications. The unit takes the weight and speed information from a belt conveyor system and accurately calculates the rate and total ...

Read more...
Ultra-compact weighing electronics
March 2020, Siemens Digital Industries , Mass Measurement
Siwarex WP351 is Siemens’ newest solution for intelligent weighing automation. Measuring 20 mm width by 65 mm height, the module is one of the smallest weighing electronics units available. The device’s ...

Read more...
A real-time alternative to radiometric density measurement
September 2019, Endress+Hauser South Africa , Mass Measurement
Currently, in mining applications, radiometric measurement has been the only way to measure the density of slurry. Until recently, and due to the harsh and abrasive environment of slurry, no other measuring ...

Read more...
What is the next big thing in Coriolis mass flowmeters?
June 2019, KROHNE , Mass Measurement
With such fast moving technology it can be difficult to forecast the ‘next big thing’, but it is possible to focus on two recent developments that look set to influence the market in the near future: high capacity flowmeters; and the ability of Coriolis meters to measure liquids with entrained gas.

Read more...
Taking the air out of dairy
May 2019, Endress+Hauser South Africa , Mass Measurement
The dairy industry has been plagued for years with the challenge of accurate flow measurement in both processing and offloading applications. Often, the most common cause of inaccuracies in flow measurement ...

Read more...
Small and powerful weighing indicator
Africa Automation Fair 2019 Preview, Richter Scale Co. , Mass Measurement
Specially developed for devices and machines which control limit values via weight measurements, Richter Scale’s SMART-2 is a small and simple weighing indicator with a rugged and durable housing. It ...

Read more...
Mass flow measurement of gases
November 2018, Instrotech , Mass Measurement
The Kobold MAS mass flowmeter works according to the calorimetric method and was conceived for gas flow measurement. Since gases can be compressed, the volume changes with pressure and temperature. In ...

Read more...
Mechanical density meter
July 2018, Instrotech , Mass Measurement
Whether dealing with the concentration or the mixing ratio, the density of liquid media is of high importance in processes such as the food or chemical industry. Kobold’s DWF mechanical density meter ...

Read more...
Mettler Toledo’s weighing control terminal for chemical processes
May 2018, Microsep , Mass Measurement
Profinet interface added to Mettler Toledo’s popular weighing control system.

Read more...
Proline Promass Q 300/500
February 2018, Endress+Hauser South Africa , Mass Measurement
The specialist for challenging applications with superior accuracy for mass, volume flow and density determination.

Read more...