classic | mobile


SA Instrumentation & Control Buyers' Guide

Technews Industry Guide - IIoT 2018

Technews Industry Guide - Maintenance, Reliability & Asset Optimisation


Are you in the clear?
June 2012, Electrical Power & Protection

Corporate South Africa is moving more and more in the direction of good corporate governance. In the recent past, the King III Report provided a framework whereby company directors are obliged to ensure governance is maintained at a level whereby key stakeholders such as shareholders, bondholders, employees and various other interested parties are protected against poor company control measures that can result in a disastrous outcome.

Forming a key part of this report, and indeed in any corporate governance strategy, is the mitigation of risk through effective management. When outlining a risk management strategy, identification of key assets that require risk protection is an area that needs considerable attention. Such assets usually include electrical reticulation systems that include substations and transformers or information storage and communications systems. Should an event cause a significant power outage, this can lead to major business downtime or if sensitive data gets lost this can be catastrophic in terms of business privacy and records. Other key infrastructure that should be included in any risk mitigation strategy would be key processing equipment that directly influences the output of a business, such as production equipment that could include conveyors, manufacturing equipment and vehicles.

The effects of fire can be devastating not only to businesses but indeed to human life too. Should a fire occur it can render serious damage in terms of business profits as well as unnecessary recapitalisation and litigation in the event of injury or loss of life. Insurance companies recognise this and usually require the implementation of fire protection systems before they will provide risk cover.

When seeking out a best solution in terms of fire protection a proper risk analysis should be done. A Weighted Risk Assessment Criteria (WRAC) is an example of a risk management tool that evaluates the risk areas by analysing the likelihood of occurrence and the possible outcomes and consequences.

The table shows how to place sources of risk against probability and consequence. An example could be an electrical fire occurring in a building’s Eskom Feed Substation Room. Such an event would be placed under occasional with the consequence being catastrophic. The primary cause of all substation fires lies in the high energy electrical switchgear. Typically a fire occurs in the cable termination compartment where the cable connection becomes increasingly hot to a point where it ignites. If this occurs a series of events could happen, for example the fire itself would destroy this room and possibly those surrounding. Typically an Eskom Feed Substation is placed in the underground parking basement with other potential fire sources – an oil filled transformer, diesel backup generators, cars that have rubber tyres and petrol in the fuel tanks etc. Should a fire occur on this piece of equipment, it would place this risk in the Unacceptable High Category that is designated as RED in the 1.4 box.

By implementing a fire detection and fire extinguishing system would reduce the risk profile to the GREEN 3.2 where the consequence would be marginal Moderate Low level. However, what is also crucial to factor in is the type of fire protection system used.

For example, should a building have a tenant that has a large paper archive room and a water sprinkler system was installed this would reduce the risk of fire damage but would introduce the factor of extensive water damage to the very documents that are intended for protection. Therefore the research into the selection of a fire protection system is crucial. In terms of a paper archive, an inert gaseous fire extinguishing system would be appropriate.

Other examples would be in a server room where gaseous extinguishing systems are typically used. The hazardous by-products of some gaseous extinguishing systems can have toxic and corrosive side effects on servers, networking devices and hard drives. The hydrofluorocarbon gases used in some types of extinguishing systems break-down into hydrogen fluoride, hydrofluoric acid is devastating on some materials. It is not surprising that the market trends have moved towards inert gas blend type extinguishing systems where there are no hazardous by-products associated because they typically constitute a blend of nitrogen and argon that are found in the air.

Fire detection devices should also be appropriate for the application. The most common fire detector is a point type optical smoke detector. However such detectors can only detect fires when the fire reaches a certain stage. Namely that there is prescribed level of smoke concentration before the detector activates. This is perfectly suitable for most applications and provides an excellent budget friendly option, but for specific applications this response time may be too late as sensitive equipment is already on fire and has begun affecting other equipment. Therefore other types of fire detectors should be considered in order to detect fire earlier and thereby reduce the risk level down to at least a moderate low level as shown on the WRAC table. An example could be in any room or area that has electrical cable runs, servers, building ducting etc.

Therefore users of risk analysis tools should go one step further in considering the effects of using certain fire protection systems and the possible side effects they could have on the very assets they are intending to protect. The type of fire protection system should be factored into the risk model itself. It is therefore very important that risk managers consult qualified engineering professionals who specialise in the field of fire protection engineering.

For more information contact Grant Wilkinson, Alien Systems & Technologies, +27 (0)11 949 1157,,

Supplied By: Alien Systems & Technologies
Tel: +27 11 949 1157
Fax: 086 718 3430
Share via email     Share via LinkedIn   Print this page

Further reading:

  • Efficient lighthouse operation in the modern age
    December 2018, Horne Technologies, Electrical Power & Protection
    In a lighthouse the structures may appear old and dignified, but the technology inside is modern and robust. Low operating costs, availability and long maintenance intervals are the decisive criteria ...
  • Evolving power management for intelligent buildings
    December 2018, Schneider Electric South Africa, Electrical Power & Protection
    Without doubt, managing energy costs while driving sustainability and efficiency is one of the biggest power management challenges that facility professionals face today. While advances in technology ...
  • Siemens launches Distributed Energy System for Africa
    December 2018, Siemens Digital Factory & Process Indust. & Drives, Electrical Power & Protection
    Africa’s energy transition is happening now. Population and economic growth are major factors that play a role in increased energy consumption and the evolving energy landscape. The era of the Internet ...
  • PyroStorm provides cost-effective fire protection for control equipment
    December 2018, Alien Systems & Technologies, IS & Ex
    If you work at a large industrial plant or mine, you may have noticed those hydraulic lubricating oil packs, or perhaps the diesel generator sets, oil store rooms, pump rooms or flammable liquids stores, ...
  • Railway current and voltage transducers
    November 2018, Denver Technical Products, Electrical Power & Protection
    Swiss manufacturer LEM has released its new traction catalogue describing railway current and voltage transducers. The new catalogue outlines the various technologies used by an isolated transducer design, ...
  • Yokogawa releases high-voltage ­analog input module
    November 2018, Yokogawa South Africa, Electrical Power & Protection
    Yokogawa has announced the availability of the GX90XA-10-V1 high-voltage analog input module. This new product has been released as part of the OpreX Data Acquisition family of data collection and control ...
  • Don’t forget to test your fire protection systems before the holiday shutdown
    November 2018, Alien Systems & Technologies, IS & Ex
    As the year draws to a close, it is natural that people start looking forward to the holidays. It is therefore quite easy to neglect to consider the damaging effect a fire could have on businesses during ...
  • Medium-voltage switchgear that doesn’t require SF6
    November 2018, Siemens Digital Factory & Process Indust. & Drives, Electrical Power & Protection
    At this year’s Hannover Messe, Siemens presented another medium-voltage switchgear that doesn’t require SF6 as the insulating gas, the 8DAB 12. The system uses clean air consisting only of the natural ...
  • Prevent unplanned outages
    November 2018, Siemens Digital Factory & Process Indust. & Drives, Electrical Power & Protection
    Siemens offers comprehensive onsite assessment solutions to keep its customers’ switchgear systems up and running.
  • Effective UPS monitoring
    October 2018, Schneider Electric South Africa, Electrical Power & Protection
    For more than three decades, the cornerstone of network reliability and availability – the uninterruptible power supply (UPS) – has ensured the protection of hardware, software and data for small, medium ...
  • Extensive electric motor range from Zest
    October 2018, Zest WEG Group, Electrical Power & Protection
    Electric motor applications require a reliable, robust fit-for-purpose product that gives the end user the requisite low total cost of ownership. Fanie Steyn, manager for rotating machines at Zest WEG ...
  • Power pack with industrial Ethernet and diagnostics
    October 2018, Instrotech, Electrical Power & Protection
    The motorised size changeover of machine spindles or machine axes is now being implemented in various ways. The solutions to this are often relatively rudimentary with no hand-wheel or crank being rotated, ...

Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual


    classic | mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.