Industrial Wireless


WiFi? Why not?

May 2017 Industrial Wireless

Despite its image as a consumer-level technology, WiFi is actually an ideal basis for an effective, low-cost mobile data network with wide area coverage. When used correctly, WiFi is a perfect fit for many applications that need highly mobile network access, including automated warehousing and public transportation.

Fifty years ago, fully automated warehouses and robotic factories were only seen in movies. But with the progress in robotic and wireless technologies in the past five years, they have now become a reality. Mobile wireless technologies also open the door to numerous other attractive applications, such as vehicle tracking for public transport and freight networks. In fact, for many years, some degree of mobile wireless data communication has been possible in those applications. The cellphone network can provide the basic infrastructure for data coverage. But, regrettably, due to limitations of latency, bandwidth and cost, most industrial applications have been unable to take full advantage of practical, reliable and affordable real time mobile control and communication. In fact, in addition to these issues, cellular-based data may add unnecessary expense to many applications, if they only actually require wireless coverage over some parts of a relatively small, predefined area, such as a stockyard, vehicle depot, warehouse, bus route or metro line.

Today, with continuing improvements in WiFi/802.11 technology, including higher bandwidth protocols, IP-based networking and faster roaming between access points, users are finally able to use WiFi to construct a reliable mobile wireless communication system that takes advantage of all the latest innovations to deliver substantial cost savings, easier setup and maintenance, and greater operational efficiency.

However, outdoor and industrial WiFi applications do have some special demands when it comes to protecting radios and other electronics from manmade hazards, such as electrically-noisy or unstable power sources and intense radio frequency interference, and natural dangers, including lightning, and static electricity – not to mention environmental issues such as extreme temperatures, vibration, dust and humidity.

Electrical issues can be especially challenging and costly because they cause intermittent, hard-to-diagnose failures in random components, which may lead to repeated maintenance downtime and unnecessary replacement of affected equipment, if the root cause of the electrical disturbance remains undiscovered.

This whitepaper explains some typical applications and highlights the key factors to consider when designing a reliable mobile wireless communication network.

Mobile WiFi enables the IIoT

Although the ‘Internet of Things’ concept has been around for some years, global deployment of IoT networks has increased rapidly during the last 12 months, and the concept is spreading to industry with the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT). The IoT centralises data through wireless technology and uses machine learning and big data analysis to turn that data into valuable information. Bringing this concept to legacy industrial applications can reduce costs, increase productivity and maximise uptime.

The IIoT often requires many devices to use WiFi simultaneously. The technologies and concepts in this white paper are key IIoT enablers, because they make it much easier for multiple, mobile devices to share WiFi without problems, thanks to new technologies like Turbo Roaming, and good practices like careful network design and avoidance of hidden nodes.

Business benefits

For mobile data communications, WiFi and cellular (mobile 3G/4G, etc) are the two most commonly-used technologies. For very wide-area coverage, such as freight vehicle tracking, cellular tends to be the best choice. But for local area mobile communication, such as smart warehouses, or for fixed-route vehicles, such as bus to depot/stop communication, WiFi is usually a better choice.

Unlike cellular, WiFi does not have monthly charges or data caps and there are no complications involving cellular service providers, billing, cell tower outages, and so on. Compared to Bluetooth and Zigbee, WiFi technology provides higher bandwidth and a relatively longer range – and it also has a proven history of backwards-compatible upgrades – so WiFi provides much greater headroom for future system enhancement and expansion. Unlike proprietary wireless data systems, WiFi is a standard protocol, based on the IEEE 802.11 specification, that is supported by hardware from many different vendors. So WiFi-based systems avoid the risk of vendor lock-in and ensure a longer design life than proprietary radio technologies.

As we have discussed, WiFi is currently the most suitable technology for local area mobile communication in many cases, because it offers a unique set of advantages. We can summarise WiFi’s main benefits as follows:

• Lower operational and maintenance cost.

• Future-proof technology with higher bandwidth available for future expansion.

• Very wide technology support from numerous vendors and hence longer system design lifetime.

Common WiFi mobility applications and their challenges

Material handling and automatic warehousing system

In a traditional warehouse, dispensers spend most of their time walking between shelves to store and retrieve items. As the scale of the warehouses increases, there is also an increase in the proportion of the time that staff must use moving from location to location, and an increase in costly human error due to misplaced items and other causes. Various types of AGV (automated guided vehicle) and AS/RS (automated storage and retrieval systems) have been introduced, using automation to resolve these problems.

One useful example is the automated warehouse system introduced by Kiva (now known as Amazon Robotics) and Amazon in 2011. These robots move the shelves horizontally to help staff to store and retrieve products more quickly and accurately. Even though this system does not utilise vertical space as well as other AS/RS systems, it can be deployed faster and provides better scalability for medium and small warehouses. A key factor required to make AGV, AS/RS or robotic systems successful is selecting the most suitable wireless technology and implementing it correctly. In our experience, we have seen several common wireless problems in warehouse applications:

Challenge #1: Roaming reliability – WiFi has limited signal coverage, so multiple access points are necessary for full coverage throughout an entire warehouse. It is critical to ensure that the clients can roam smoothly between these access points with minimal handover time.

Challenge #2: Power supply quality – robots and other mobile devices often have very limited space and weight-carrying capacity for a WiFi module, and the power system usually cannot be properly grounded. So system integrators must dedicate considerable effort to ensuring onboard devices cannot be affected by the inrush current (a surge of power commonly created when electrical devices switch on or start moving) that is created by the robot’s motors – otherwise there is even a risk that electronics could burn out or suffer significantly reduced lifespan.

Challenge #3: Communication blockage – Unfortunately, metal is extremely effective at blocking radio signals, and large metal objects, such as vehicles and metal shelving, are common in industrial, freight and transport environments. System integrators need wireless expertise and experience to devise the most efficient positioning of APs and antennas, in order to avoid the risk of communication blind spots caused by stationary or moving metal objects.

Challenge #4: System adaptability – there are many kinds of warehouses; some require special environments, such as very high or low humidity, or sub-zero storage temperatures. System integrators need to be able build a system that is adaptable to different customer needs and many different environments. So it is important to choose hardware that can handle extreme temperature ranges and has good ingress protection to keep out dust and moisture.

Building a reliable mobile WiFi system with the Moxa AWK-A series

Moxa’s AWK series devices meet these challenges through incorporation of the following:

• Advanced roaming technology with client-based Turbo Roaming.

• Rugged hardware design with dual isolation.

• DFS channel support.

• Industrial-grade production and reliability.

These features provide all the basic building blocks of a reliable, high-performance mobile WiFi network. The AWK-1131A can be integrated into mobile clients providing all of Moxa’s seamless roaming technologies, while the AWK-3131A and the AWK-4131A are ideal fixed access points for indoor and outdoor use respectively. All units have Moxa’s Dual Isolation technology, providing electrical isolation features suitable for their designated usage, with 500 V insulation and level 4 ESD protection. The AWK-4131A offers IP68 ingress protection – particularly suited to outdoor use where direct exposure to rain, strong winds and dust or grit is a common hazard. The other units are shielded by IP30 ingress protection.



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Wireless, smartphone-operated sound level meters
TANDM Technologies Industrial Wireless
Local test and measurement company, TANDM has introduced the Brüel & Kjaer wireless, smartphone-operated 2245 and 2255 sound level meters to the South African market.

Read more...
Safeguarding an energy storage system for renewable energy
RJ Connect Electrical Power & Protection
Following the trend toward decarbonising the global economy, a grid-level energy storage system (ESS) builder is expanding its ESS capacity for renewable energy. Its mission is to provide a reliable and affordable ESS, as this is key for grid operators to be able to balance power demand and supply during peak and off-peak times.

Read more...
Assessing the order of events
Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists Industrial Wireless
Being able to monitor plant alarms and events in real time, in chronological order, is critical when a plant experiences an avalanche of alarms caused by an abnormal event. Sequence of events modules can be used to cut unplanned plant downtime and reduce operational costs.

Read more...
How to simplify traffic management in smart cities
RJ Connect IT in Manufacturing
Online teaser: In an increasingly urbanised world, cities must find innovative solutions to overcome challenges such as traffic congestion, longer commutes and increased CO2 emissions. Adopting futureproof traffic management technologies is the key to addressing these issues effectively.

Read more...
Protecting Australia’s harbours from a silent threat
Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists Industrial Wireless
Omniflex has completed the addition of remote monitoring to the existing cathodic protection (CP) systems at five berths in Port Kembla, Australia. This will enhance their surveillance and provide accurate energy monitoring.

Read more...
Unleashing the future of mining
RJ Connect IT in Manufacturing
With the demand for critical minerals for the clean energy transition surging, the World Bank predicts a 500% increase in their production by 2050. For the mining industry, this means unprecedented growth. But it also faces a plethora of internal and external challenges. In response to these constant changes, mining operations are proactively embracing digital transformation, leveraging technologies such as automation, unmanned systems and AI for image recognition to enhance operational efficiency and safety.

Read more...
RFID made simple
Pepperl+Fuchs Industrial Wireless
Pepperl+Fuchs now offers a practical solution for users looking for an easy entry into the world of RFID with all its possibilities. The new F191 RFID read/write device combines the advantages of sophisticated industrial UHF technology with a standardised interface for IO-link communication.

Read more...
Futureproofing networks
RJ Connect IT in Manufacturing
The rise of smart manufacturing has seen a growing number of cyberthreats in the industrial sector as an unintended consequence of the convergence of IT and OT. While this achieves better efficiency and creates greater value, it also exposes traditionally isolated OT systems to all kinds of cyberattacks.

Read more...
How lighting solutions support lean manufacturing processes
Turck Banner Southern Africa Editor's Choice Industrial Wireless
The philosophy of lean principles is a big trend in the pharmaceutical industry. It emphasises using time and resources as efficiently as possible in order to reduce waste and focus on value-added activities. Here are four examples of how lighting solutions can help increase efficiency by addressing common sources of wasted time and resources in pharmaceutical manufacturing.

Read more...
A new era of power: large-scale battery energy storage systems
RJ Connect Electrical Power & Protection
As the sun sets on coal power, we are seeing the rise of large-scale battery energy storage systems (BESS), together with a surge in renewable energy capacity. So what is the secret to ensuring a successful energy transition?

Read more...