classic | mobile
 

Search...

SA Instrumentation & Control Buyers' Guide

Technews Industry Guide - IIoT 2018

Technews Industry Guide - Maintenance, Reliability & Asset Optimisation

 

Open warfare
June 2009, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking


Supporters of open building automation standards should themselves remain open as the two main protocols overlap.

Open protocols were conceived as part of an end user backlash against the proprietary building automation and control systems that were traditionally a staple of the market. In the past, if a customer wanted to expand or change their building systems, they were typically locked into using the original supplier of the control system. The rationale for developing open protocols was to prevent this ‘lock-in’ by allowing users the ability to ‘mix and match’ products from different vendors and easily integrate them for management purposes.

Today, most organisations are aligned with one of two key open protocols for automation and control – LonWorks or BACnet. The decision to go down either path can be dependent on a number of factors, for example: the level of integration required in a particular room or zone, the factory-standard controls provided with the building equipment, and future building expansion plans. However, the alignment of the consulting engineer to the project is just as likely to be a key influence.

The trend for open protocols in recent months is one of overlap and convergence. LonWorks, which derives its strength from device-to-device integration, is moving upmarket at a time when open rival, BACnet, known in the high-level system-to-system integration space, is executing a ‘top-down’ approach. The resulting overlap in capabilities means it is now possible for organisations to have a perfectly functional end-to-end automation and control system using either protocol.

Achieving an environment that mixes both protocols, however, is still a fairly complex task. As the overlap in standards becomes more pronounced, the willingness of vendors to support both protocols, either separately or together, will become increasingly important from a future-proofing perspective. The same vendor’s ability to provide systems integration and consultancy support may also prove advantageous in the long term, particularly as the need for integrated LonWorks and BACnet environments increases.

How the standards evolved

LonWorks is the control networking technology platform developed by Echelon Corporation. In 1994, Echelon also created LonMark – a governing body with a set of guidelines and strict testing process to certify the interoperability of LonWorks-based solutions from multiple manufacturers – a critical element to ensure the platform can act as a global open standard. LonWorks is generally considered the best solution for device-level connectivity – for example, enabling the controller that modulates the damper for airflow in a particular room to communicate locally with a lighting controller from another manufacturer.

The American Society for Heating Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) developed the other open protocol, BACnet – starting in 1987 and finishing almost a decade later – initially as an enabler for system-to-system integration. The protocol has since evolved to be included in control devices as well. ‘Native BACnet’ solutions are often promoted as the only true open standards by followers, based on the protocol’s development origins from within an ASHRAE industry group as opposed to coming from a private company. The argument does not appear to have negatively affected sales of LonWorks controllers globally, which so far outnumber BACnet-based solutions. In saying that, BACnet can boast a relatively strong following among government and higher education organisations, based on its status as a more openly developed protocol and broad acceptance within the academic and consulting engineer fraternities.

It is currently not possible for LonWorks and BACnet platforms to interoperate without a gateway device that converts one protocol to the other. It is technically possible for either a BACnet or LonWorks device to share a common LonTalk bus to transport messages using their separate control languages (in the same way the devices can communicate over Ethernet) although, in practice, this is rarely done.

Decisive factors for open adoption

As the standards continue to evolve, interoperability is likely to become a key issue. Manufacturers, systems integrators and other professional services firms that remain open to both protocols rather than aligning with either camp will likely have a natural advantage over competitors who do not embrace the relevant standards.

A key factor in any successful building system implementation is a trained and knowledgeable vendor to design the system, write the applications and make the right technology choices to enable efficient operation and maintenance, while accommodating future expansion needs.

While a LonWorks only or BACnet only based solution can work, adherence to a single protocol can create increased complexity and cost, particularly from a long-term maintenance and future expansion perspective.

Emerging standards such as Open Building Information exchange (oBIX) – a protocol for exchanging building information using XML (therefore making it more consistent with Information Technology standards) – further justifies the need to choose a platform with multi-protocol support. These types of solutions will prove far more cost-effective over the life of the building system than those that work with a single protocol.

Making top-tier control accessible

One of the key benefits of open standards is that they have essentially commoditised the automation and control systems market. Cheaper electronics, together with the number of providers with open standards-based solutions, has levelled the playing field both in terms of upfront purchase costs and the functionality manufacturers are able to build into their devices.

While there is little doubt integration and interoperability have improved with the advent of open standards, anecdotal evidence suggests that less than 20% of the commercial building market has embraced the concept to create a true multivendor environment. In reality, up to 80% of organisations – and maybe more – still buy most of their equipment from one vendor. The recent trend away from best-of-breed ‘point’ solution-based environments to end-to-end, single vendor platforms means this trend may continue for some time.

Ultimately open protocol-based devices have benefited the market as a whole. The next challenge – and opportunity – for systems integrators in the space will be ensuring they have the ability to offer either BACnet or LonWorks-based devices or a ‘best of both worlds’ type approach, tailored to the customer’s requirements. At the same time, organisations currently participating in tender processes should ensure the systems integrator or service provider they select has the flexibility to offer multiple control options to ensure the system provided today can scale to meet any future needs in this space.

Richard Creighton
Richard Creighton

For more information contact Debbie Rae, Honeywell Southern Africa, +27 (0)11 695 8000, hsa@honeywell.com, www.honeywell.co.za


Credit(s)
Supplied By: Honeywell ACS South Africa
Tel: +27 11 695 8000
Fax: 0800 981 754
Email: hsa@honeywell.com
www: www.honeywellprocess.com
Share via email     Share via LinkedIn   Print this page

Further reading:

  • Is HART technology still useful as manufacturing moves to Industry 4.0?
    December 2018, Pepperl+Fuchs, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    With its bidirectional communication between intelligent field devices and host systems, HART has become a global standard. The example of valves shows how important the data provided by field devices ...
  • New patch panel for Ethernet networks
    November 2018, Phoenix Contact, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    Time savings of up to 60%.
  • Bus couplers in accordance with Profinet
    October 2018, Phoenix Contact, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    In Profinet applications, the Axioline F bus coupler is the link between the Axioline F system and the higher-level Ethernet system. As Phoenix Contact’s first Profinet bus coupler, the TPS version of ...
  • Prepare for the future
    September 2018, RET Automation Controls, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    Bring serial interfaces into the era of Industry 4.0.
  • Secure remote access to plants with Profibus
    August 2018, Siemens Digital Factory & Process Indust. & Drives, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    Siemens has extended its portfolio of industrial routers with the Scalance M804PB, which allows existing machines and plants to be connected to Ethernet networks via Profibus/MPI (multi-point interface). ...
  • Modernising the Cholfirst Tunnel control engineering system
    July 2018, Phoenix Contact, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    The Swiss A4 highway is an important transit route for north-south traffic. Every day, over 25 000 vehicles use the northern section of the A4 that also serves as the Schaffhausen expressway and is a ...
  • Industrial fieldbus to the IIoT
    Technews Industry Guide: Industrial Internet of Things & Industry 4.0, Industrial Data Xchange (IDX), Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    The promise of Industry 4.0 and the IIoT is that they can harness this shift, along with the global connectivity platform of the Internet, and recent IP stack extensions such as Time Sensitive Networking ...
  • Intelligent production enables minimised downtime and optimal efficiency
    Technews Industry Guide: Industrial Internet of Things & Industry 4.0, Parker Hannifin Sales Company South, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    IO-Link supports predictive maintenance strategy with flexibility in the Industry 4.0 era.
  • EtherCAT: the rock in the surf of digital transformation
    Technews Industry Guide: Industrial Internet of Things & Industry 4.0, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    Industry 4.0 is the digital transformation that is characterised as the fourth industrial revolution. The perception of a revolution is that it is a fast process, dramatically changing the current situation ...
  • IO-Link master for the IIoT world
    June 2018, ifm Electronic RSA, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    The IO-Link master modules for the control cabinet serve as a gateway between intelligent IO-Link sensors and the fieldbus, allowing important information from intelligent sensors to be sent into the ...
  • Substation retrofit gives IEC 61850 MMS solution
    June 2018, RJ Connect, Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
    A regional substation was tasked with improving the substation’s performance and reducing maintenance problems, but without replacing several key serial IEDs already in operation. Since the many RTUs, ...
  • Honeywell and Equate agree to enhance productivity of petrochemical plants in Kuwait
    April 2018, Honeywell ACS South Africa, News
    Honeywell and Equate Petrochemical Company have announced the signing of a memorandum of understanding to further the development of innovative technologies to support operations at Equate’s industrial ...

 
 
         
Contact:
Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Other
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual





 

         
    classic | mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.